Pizzerias in New York Albany Eat & Drink Food & Drink in NYC Locations New York City New York State Pizzerias Restaurants in New York Restaurants in NYC

10 Best Pizzerias on 5th Avenue NYC

Admin_AZ_New_York March 1, 2026

142 11 minutes read

79 / 100

SEO Score

Table of Contents

10 Best Pizzerias on 5th Avenue NYC

A guide to finding artisanal pies and classic slices just steps away from Manhattan’s most famous retail corridor.

5th Avenue is the undisputed backbone of Manhattan, dividing the city into East and West while serving as one of the most expensive and famous shopping streets in the world. Stretching from Washington Square Park all the way to Harlem, its most iconic stretch runs through Midtown, passing landmarks like the Empire State Building, Rockefeller Center, and the southeastern corner of Central Park. At its 59th Street intersection, it is located approximately 0.4 miles east of New York City’s official ground zero at Columbus Circle.

When evaluating the pizzeria segment along the prime Midtown stretch of 5th Avenue, there are an estimated 12 dedicated, high-quality pizza establishments within a one-block radius. This relatively low number directly on the avenue itself is due to astronomical commercial retail rents.

Consequently, the best pizza is strategically hidden just off the main avenue on the immediate side streets. These shops are masterfully designed to feed a relentless tide of international tourists, luxury shoppers, and corporate executives with speed and precision.

This guide, a special curation by AZ New York, using insights from NYC Tourism, is your essential map to the best pizza near Manhattan’s legendary avenue.

“Embrace the incentive to step off the crowded retail avenue to find a world-class New York slice, while practicing prudence by checking prices, as Midtown dining can carry a premium.”

You might be interested in Pizzerias in these nearby locations

Location	Est. # of Pizzerias	Distance (from 5th Ave)
Rockefeller Center	Concourse Slices	~0.1 miles
Bryant Park	Artisan & Square	~0.1 miles
Grand Central Terminal	Corporate & Fast	~0.3 miles
Central Park South	Icons & Coal Oven	~0.0 miles (at 59th St)
Flatiron District	Neapolitan & Trendy	~0.0 miles (at 23rd St)
Times Square	High Volume Slices	~0.4 miles

Pizzeria Guides in Neighboring Areas

3 Case Studies: Enjoying Pizza Near 5th Avenue

Case 1: The Holiday Shopper. After viewing the Christmas windows at Saks Fifth Avenue, a family needs immediate warmth and food. Instead of waiting an hour for a sit-down restaurant, they walk one block east to Little Italy Pizza on 43rd Street, grabbing massive, hot slices in under five minutes.
Case 2: The Museum Mile Explorer. A tourist finishes touring the Metropolitan Museum of Art on 5th Avenue and 82nd Street. Craving authentic coal-oven pizza, they walk over to Lexington Avenue to sit down and enjoy a full pie at the historic Mariella Pizza.
Case 3: The Flatiron Architect. A designer working near the Flatiron Building needs an upscale lunch with a client. They walk directly into Eataly on 5th Avenue and 23rd Street, enjoying an authentic, wood-fired Neapolitan pizza paired with Italian wine.

Curiosity

5th Avenue acts as the geographical dividing line for Manhattan’s street grid. Any street address west of 5th Avenue is designated “West” (e.g., 10 West 42nd Street), and any address east is designated “East”. This makes navigating to the pizzerias on the side streets incredibly intuitive!

Tip

Never look for a pizzeria with an actual “5th Avenue” address in Midtown. Because retail spaces here command thousands of dollars per square foot, small slice shops cannot survive on the avenue itself. Always look down the immediate cross streets (like 43rd, 46th, or 57th) to find the hidden culinary gems.

“Let the proximity to world-class museums and parks incentivize your pizza hunt, but act with prudence by securing a table during the chaotic midday corporate lunch rush.”

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. Are there any pizzerias directly on 5th Avenue?

In Midtown, it is extremely rare due to retail costs. However, in the Flatiron District, Eataly sits directly on 5th Avenue and houses an incredible Neapolitan pizza restaurant.

2. Where is the best pizza near the Empire State Building?

Located right off 5th Avenue at 34th Street, your best bet is walking a few blocks west towards Penn Station for NY Pizza Suprema, or heading slightly north to Previti Pizza near Bryant Park.

3. What is the closest slice to Rockefeller Center’s 5th Avenue entrance?

Little Italy Pizza on 43rd Street is a very short, easy walk south from Rockefeller Center, offering incredibly fast and reliable New York street slices.

4. Can I find coal-oven pizza near Central Park South and 5th Ave?

Yes. Angelo’s Pizza on 57th Street is located just a couple of blocks west of 5th Avenue and is famous for its historically accurate, thin-crust coal-fired pies.

5. Is there good pizza near the Metropolitan Museum of Art?

The Met sits on 5th Avenue at 82nd Street. To find the best pizza, you must walk east into the Upper East Side towards Lexington or 2nd Avenue, where spots like San Matteo offer exceptional Neapolitan pies.

6. What style of pizza is most common in this area?

Midtown is dominated by fast-casual, gas-oven New York slice shops catering to office workers. However, you will also find several high-end Italian restaurants offering wood-fired pizzas for corporate lunches.

7. Can I get a gluten-free pizza near the shopping district?

Yes. Upscale locations like Eataly Flatiron and various sit-down Italian restaurants along 55th and 57th Streets are highly accommodating and offer excellent gluten-free crusts.

8. Is it safe to carry a pizza box down 5th Avenue?

Absolutely. 5th Avenue is heavily policed and generally packed with pedestrians. Carrying a pizza box is a classic New York move, though navigating the dense crowds near Rockefeller Center can be tricky.

9. How much does pizza cost near the luxury stores?

While the clothes on 5th Avenue cost thousands, a classic cheese slice on a nearby cross street will still only cost you between $3.50 and $4.50, making it the most affordable meal in the district.

10. Do any of these pizzerias have outdoor seating?

Many slice shops do not, but you can easily take your slice to the outdoor tables at Bryant Park (at 42nd Street) or the public plazas near the Flatiron Building (at 23rd Street) to eat outside.

Ranking: 10 Best Pizzerias on and around 5th Avenue

Below, check out the ranking of the 10 best pizzerias located just steps off the legendary avenue, in a special curation by AZ New York.

1. La Pizza & La Pasta at Eataly (Flatiron)

Located directly on 5th Avenue where it intersects with Broadway at 23rd Street. This massive Italian marketplace features a sit-down restaurant serving impeccably authentic, wood-fired Neapolitan pizzas.
Address: 200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010
Phone: (212) 229-2560
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: eataly.com
Must-Try Pies: Margherita Verace, Quattro Formaggi.

2. Angelo’s Pizza

Situated just off 5th Avenue near Central Park South. This famous bi-level establishment serves iconic coal-oven pizza. The crust is thin, rigid, and beautifully smoky, making it a perfect post-shopping dinner.
Address: 117 W 57th St, New York, NY 10019
Phone: (212) 333-4333
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: angelospizzany.com
Must-Try Pies: Traditional Coal Oven Pie, White Pizza.

3. Little Italy Pizza (43rd St)

Located just a few steps east of 5th Avenue, this classic, high-volume slice joint is a savior for tourists and office workers alike. They provide large, greasy, perfectly foldable New York slices.
Address: 11 E 43rd St, New York, NY 10017
Phone: (212) 687-3660
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: Not available.
Must-Try Slices: Plain Cheese, Mushroom Slice.

4. Previti Pizza

Situated slightly east of 5th Avenue near the Public Library. Previti is renowned among corporate workers for its incredible focaccia-style square slices, offering a thick, airy, and deeply flavorful crust.
Address: 123 E 41st St, New York, NY 10168
Phone: (212) 557-4992
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: previtipizza.com
Must-Try Slices: Artichoke Focaccia Slice, Roast Beef Pizza.

5. Pizza By Certe

Located just east of 5th Avenue in the 50s. This is New York’s first “green” pizzeria, utilizing eco-friendly practices and locally sourced ingredients to create incredibly unique, health-conscious artisanal squares.
Address: 132 E 56th St, New York, NY 10022
Phone: (212) 813-2020
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: certenyc.com
Must-Try Slices: The Shroom Slice, Vegan Options.

6. Roberta’s (Urbanspace Vanderbilt)

A short walk east from 5th Avenue at 45th Street brings you to this food hall outpost of the legendary Brooklyn brand. They serve immaculate, individual-sized wood-fired Neapolitan pies perfect for a quick lunch.
Address: 230 Park Ave (Inside Urbanspace), New York, NY 10169
Phone: (646) 747-0820
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: robertaspizza.com
Must-Try Pies: The Bee Sting, Famous Original.

7. Carnegie Pizza

Located just a block west of 5th Avenue near Bryant Park. This exceptionally clean, modern slice shop delivers very crisp New York round slices and excellent Grandma squares with a vibrant tomato sauce.
Address: 200 W 41st St, New York, NY 10036
Phone: (212) 777-4141
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: carnegiepizza.com
Must-Try Slices: Vodka Square Slice, Classic Pepperoni.

8. PizzArte

A short walk west of 5th Avenue into the 50s. This bi-level space acts as a fine art gallery and an elite Neapolitan pizzeria, utilizing a massive wood-burning oven to create soft, blistered Italian pies.
Address: 69 W 55th St, New York, NY 10019
Phone: (212) 247-3936
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: pizzarteny.com
Must-Try Pies: Margherita Verace, Tartufata.

9. Joe’s Pizza (Broadway)

While located on Broadway, it is only a quick two-block walk west from 5th Avenue. It remains the absolute gold standard for the fast, flawless, classic NYC street slice.
Address: 1435 Broadway, New York, NY 10018
Phone: (646) 559-4878
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: joespizzanyc.com
Must-Try Slices: The Classic Cheese Slice.

10. Mariella Pizza

For those exploring 5th Avenue’s Museum Mile, walking a few blocks east to Lexington Avenue reveals this beloved local secret. It offers a classic, heavy, and satisfying old-school New York slice.
Address: 965 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10021
Phone: (212) 737-3606
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: Not available.
Must-Try Slices: Regular Cheese Slice, Sicilian Square.

All research and the final selection of the pizzerias in this guide were carried out by the team at AZ New York.

Keywords for your next internet searches (Palavras-chaves para suas próximas buscas na internet)

best pizza 5th Avenue NYC, Eataly Flatiron pizza, Angelos Pizza 57th St, Little Italy Pizza Midtown, Previti Pizza NYC, Pizza By Certe, Robertas Urbanspace, authentic NY slice Midtown, shopping district pizza NYC, distance to Columbus Circle NYC,

top rated pizzerias Manhattan, pizza near Empire State Building, NYC food tours, quick lunch Midtown NYC, Neapolitan pizza Flatiron, coal oven pizza Manhattan, Carnegie Pizza NYC, PizzArte 55th St, Joes Pizza Broadway, pizza near Central Park South, luxury shopping NYC food, slice shop near me NYC, square pizza Midtown, pizza delivery 5th Avenue, historic pizza NYC

Explore Our Guides to New York City

Special Location Guides

Legal Notice: The information presented in this guide is based on research conducted in March 2026 and may be subject to changes in hours, prices, and availability. AZ New York has no direct commercial relationship with the establishments mentioned, acting solely as an informative guide.

1000 Best Pizzerias in New York

NYC Pizzeria Financial Engine

Authorship by AZNewYork.com

1. Monthly Fixed Costs (Burn Rate)

Base Rent + NNN

Labor (Chefs/Staff)

Energy & Gas (Ovens)

Insurance & Licensing

2. Sales Mix Strategy

Slices (High Volume): 70% Pies (High Ticket): 30%

3. COGS & Operational Waste

Ingredients (COGS) (%)

Daily Waste & Spoilage (%)

Tax & Merchant Fees (%)

Breakeven Monthly Revenue

$ 0.00

Monthly sales needed for operational survival.

Fixed Costs

$ 0.00

Daily Goal

$ 0.00

Initializing pizza data...

79 / 100

SEO Score

10 Best Pizzerias on 5th Avenue NYC

A guide to finding artisanal pies and classic slices just steps away from Manhattan’s most famous retail corridor.

You might be interested in Pizzerias in these nearby locations

3 Case Studies: Enjoying Pizza Near 5th Avenue

Curiosity

Tip

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. Are there any pizzerias directly on 5th Avenue?

2. Where is the best pizza near the Empire State Building?

3. What is the closest slice to Rockefeller Center’s 5th Avenue entrance?

4. Can I find coal-oven pizza near Central Park South and 5th Ave?

5. Is there good pizza near the Metropolitan Museum of Art?

6. What style of pizza is most common in this area?

7. Can I get a gluten-free pizza near the shopping district?

8. Is it safe to carry a pizza box down 5th Avenue?

9. How much does pizza cost near the luxury stores?

10. Do any of these pizzerias have outdoor seating?

Ranking: 10 Best Pizzerias on and around 5th Avenue

1. La Pizza & La Pasta at Eataly (Flatiron)

2. Angelo’s Pizza

3. Little Italy Pizza (43rd St)

4. Previti Pizza

5. Pizza By Certe

6. Roberta’s (Urbanspace Vanderbilt)

7. Carnegie Pizza

8. PizzArte

9. Joe’s Pizza (Broadway)

10. Mariella Pizza

Keywords for your next internet searches (Palavras-chaves para suas próximas buscas na internet)

Explore Our Guides to New York City

Special Location Guides

NYC Pizzeria Financial Engine

Top 10 Largest Multinational Corporations in NYC in 2026

Top 10 Largest Multinational Corporations in Midtown Manhattan in 2026

Related Articles

The Global Investor Challenge

Are you a Market Master?