Guide to Flatbush Avenue in New York City Eat & Drink Food & Drink in NYC Locations New York City Pizzerias Pizzerias in New York Restaurants in New York Restaurants in NYC

10 Best Pizzerias in Flatbush NYC

Admin_AZ_New_York February 22, 2026

182 10 minutes read

77 / 100

SEO Score

Table of Contents

10 Best Pizzerias in Flatbush NYC

A guide to classic slices, sourdough crusts, and Caribbean-inspired pies in the heart of Brooklyn.

Flatbush is a massive, culturally rich neighborhood located right in the center of Brooklyn. Located approximately 7.5 miles southeast of New York City’s official ground zero at Columbus Circle, it is famous for its stunning Victorian architecture, the sprawling green spaces of Prospect Park on its northern edge, and its incredibly vibrant Caribbean-American community.

When analyzing the specific culinary segment of pizzerias, Flatbush currently features an estimated 15 dedicated pizza establishments. This number beautifully reflects the neighborhood’s unique demographic evolution. You will find a fascinating dual reality here: deep-rooted, old-school Italian slice shops that have stood the test of time, sharing the avenues with a new wave of innovative restaurants creating Caribbean-pizza fusions and artisanal sourdough masterpieces. It is a neighborhood where pizza tradition meets bold, modern neighborhood culture.

This guide, a special curation by AZ New York, is your essential map to the best pizza in this dynamic Brooklyn district.

“Feel the incentive to dive into bold, Caribbean-infused pizza creations, while practicing prudence by checking subway service schedules for weekend neighborhood explorations.”

You might be interested in Pizzerias in these nearby locations

Location	Est. # of Pizzerias	Distance (from Church Ave B/Q)
Crown Heights	Icons & Kosher	~1.5 miles
Midwood	Legends & Classics	~1.0 miles
Park Slope	Family & Classic	~1.5 miles
Prospect Heights	Neighborhood spots	~1.2 miles
Bed-Stuy	Destination Pies	~2.5 miles
Sheepshead Bay	Classic & Old School	~3.0 miles

Pizzeria Guides in Neighboring Areas

4 Tips for Eating Pizza in Flatbush

Embrace Cultural Fusion: Do not miss the chance to try pizza that reflects the local culture. ZuriLee Pizza Bar offers unique Caribbean twists, like jerk chicken and oxtail toppings, that you simply cannot find anywhere else in the city.
The Midwood Border Pilgrimage: Flatbush borders Midwood to the south. This means you are remarkably close to Di Fara Pizza, an undisputed titan of American pizza history. It is a mandatory visit for any pizza lover in the area.
Cortelyou Road and Church Avenue: These two commercial strips (particularly in the Ditmas Park section of Flatbush) are the culinary epicenters. This is where you will find top-tier artisanal sourdough pies alongside bustling slice counters.
Prospect Park Picnics: If you are visiting on a sunny day, grab a pie from a spot near the northern edge of the neighborhood and take a short walk to the Parade Ground in Prospect Park for an unmatched outdoor dining experience.

“Let the unique neighborhood flavor combinations serve as your dining incentive, but act with prudence by anticipating a wait at the most critically acclaimed border spots.”

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. Is Flatbush known for a specific style of pizza?

While it has excellent traditional New York slices, Flatbush is increasingly known for its incredible diversity. You will find brilliant sourdough pizzas, classic coal-oven nearby, and unique Caribbean-Italian fusion pies.

2. What is Caribbean fusion pizza?

Pioneered in this neighborhood by spots like ZuriLee, it involves taking a high-quality, wood-fired pizza base and integrating traditional Caribbean flavors and ingredients, such as jerk chicken, saltfish, and oxtail.

3. How close is the famous Di Fara Pizza?

Di Fara Pizza is located in Midwood, which shares a direct southern border with Flatbush. It is just a short walk or a very quick train ride from the southern edges of Flatbush.

4. Are there good sit-down pizza restaurants in Flatbush?

Yes. Wheated on Church Avenue and ZuriLee on Flatbush Avenue are excellent sit-down restaurants offering fantastic ambiance, full bars, and artisanal pizzas.

5. Where can I find sourdough pizza here?

Wheated is the premier destination for sourdough pizza in Flatbush. They naturally leaven their dough, resulting in a complex, airy, and deeply flavorful crust.

6. Is it safe to explore Flatbush at night for dinner?

Yes, the main dining corridors like Cortelyou Road, Church Avenue, and Flatbush Avenue are vibrant, heavily foot-trafficked, and generally very welcoming for evening dining.

7. Can I get a classic New York slice near the subway?

Absolutely. Places like Lo Duca Pizza near Newkirk Plaza and San Remo on Cortelyou Road offer quintessential, fast, and delicious New York slices right next to the train stations.

8. Do these pizzerias offer vegan options?

Yes, the artisanal spots are very accommodating. Wheated and ZuriLee can adjust their pies for vegan diets, and many classic slice shops offer cheeseless vegetable slices upon request.

9. How do I get to Flatbush from Manhattan?

The neighborhood is highly accessible. The B and Q express trains run right through the heart of Flatbush (Church Ave, Cortelyou Rd, Newkirk Plaza), making it an easy trip from Midtown or Downtown Manhattan.

10. Do local pizzerias deliver to Prospect Park?

While they will not deliver deep into the grass, most local shops will deliver to the immediate street borders of Prospect Park, such as Parkside Avenue or Ocean Avenue, allowing you to easily pick up your food for a picnic.

Ranking: 10 Best Pizzerias in Flatbush

Below, check out the ranking of the 10 best pizzerias in the region (including essential neighboring borders), in a special curation by AZ New York.

1. ZuriLee Pizza Bar

A groundbreaking restaurant that brilliantly marries Flatbush’s Caribbean soul with artisanal pizza making. Their wood-fired pies feature incredible, highly original toppings in a stylish, energetic atmosphere.
Address: 755 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11226
Phone: (718) 513-6084
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: zurileepizza.com
Must-Try Pies: The Jerk Chicken Pie, Bake and Saltfish Pie.

2. Wheated

A destination for sourdough enthusiasts. This spacious, welcoming restaurant on Church Avenue ferments their dough naturally, producing a beautifully blistered crust. They also boast an extensive whiskey collection.
Address: 905 Church Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11218
Phone: (347) 240-2813
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: wheatedbrooklyn.com
Must-Try Pies: The Brighton Beach, The Coney Island.

3. Di Fara Pizza (nearby)

Sitting just across the border in Midwood, this legendary establishment created by the late Domenico DeMarco is often cited as the best pizza in New York. Expect a wait, a high price, and an unforgettable slice.
Address: 1424 Avenue J, Brooklyn, NY 11230
Phone: (718) 258-1367
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: difarapizzany.com
Must-Try Slices: The Classic Regular Slice, The Square Slice.

4. Lo Duca Pizza

A hidden neighborhood gem tucked away in the pedestrian-only Newkirk Plaza. This unassuming, old-school shop serves a spectacular, highly rated New York slice with a perfectly crisp undercarriage.
Address: 14 Newkirk Plaza, Brooklyn, NY 11226
Phone: (718) 859-1501
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: Not available.
Must-Try Slices: Plain Cheese Slice, Sicilian Square.

5. San Remo Pizzeria

A beloved anchor of the Cortelyou Road dining scene. San Remo provides a large, comfortable space and consistently excellent, traditional New York slices and Italian comfort food for the local community.
Address: 1408 Cortelyou Rd, Brooklyn, NY 11226
Phone: (718) 282-4915
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: sanremopizzerianewyork.com
Must-Try Slices: Grandma Slice, White Pizza.

6. Norm’s Pizza (nearby)

Located just north in Prospect Lefferts Gardens, Norm’s brings elite-level slice shop execution to the area. Their dough is phenomenal, resulting in thin, crispy, and highly digestible classic slices.
Address: 345 Adams St, Brooklyn, NY 11201 (Note: secondary location, primary is in Downtown Brooklyn, but highly ordered from the area).
Substitute closer location: Erv’s on Beekman
A neighborhood favorite just east of Flatbush, serving fantastic artisanal pies and craft cocktails in a relaxed, cozy environment.
Address: 2122 Beekman Pl, Brooklyn, NY 11225
Phone: (718) 230-0061 (Check current active number)
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: Not available.
Must-Try Pies: Classic Margherita, Spicy Sopressata.

7. Antonio’s Pizzeria

A cornerstone on Flatbush Avenue, Antonio’s has been serving generations of residents. It is the epitome of the quick, affordable, and incredibly satisfying Brooklyn corner slice joint.
Address: 318 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238
Phone: (718) 398-2300
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: Not available.
Must-Try Slices: Sausage Slice, Regular Cheese Slice.

8. Gino’s Pizza

Located on the bustling Church Avenue, Gino’s is a classic Italian-American pizzeria. They offer generous portions, a wide variety of specialty slices, and a very friendly, neighborhood vibe.
Address: 1819 Church Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11226
Phone: (718) 282-3665
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: Not available.
Must-Try Slices: Pepperoni Slice, Chicken Parm Slice.

9. Pizza Yard (nearby)

Situated just on the border of Crown Heights and Flatbush, this spot is highly popular for its massive, 20-inch thin-crust pies and creative topping combinations served in a fast-casual setting.
Address: 903 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225
Phone: (718) 221-5060
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: pizzayardny.com
Must-Try Slices: Truffle Mushroom Slice, Vodka Slice.

10. Pizzeria 33

A solid, late-night friendly slice shop serving the northern end of Flatbush Avenue. It is the perfect place to grab a reliable, hot slice after a night out or a long day exploring the city.
Address: 330 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238
Phone: (718) 230-0100
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: Not available.
Must-Try Slices: Classic Cheese, Buffalo Chicken.

All research and the final selection of the pizzerias in this guide were carried out by the team at AZ New York.

Explore Our Guides to New York City

Pizzeria Guides

Legal Notice: The information presented in this guide is based on research conducted in February 2026 and may be subject to changes in hours, prices, and availability. AZ New York has no direct commercial relationship with the establishments mentioned, acting solely as an informative guide.

SEO Keywords

best pizza Flatbush, ZuriLee Pizza Bar Brooklyn, Caribbean pizza NYC, Wheated sourdough pizza, Di Fara Pizza Brooklyn, Flatbush restaurants, Brooklyn pizza guide, authentic NY slice, Cortelyou Road pizza, Church Avenue Brooklyn food, old school Brooklyn pizza, distance to Columbus Circle pizza, top rated pizzerias NYC, Brooklyn neighborhood dining,

best slice Flatbush, Lo Duca Pizza Newkirk Plaza, San Remo Pizzeria, family friendly pizza Brooklyn, artisanal pizza NYC, NYC food tours Brooklyn, Italian American Brooklyn, Prospect Park food, late night pizza Flatbush, wood fired pizza NYC, pizza near Brooklyn College

77 / 100

SEO Score

10 Best Pizzerias in Flatbush NYC

A guide to classic slices, sourdough crusts, and Caribbean-inspired pies in the heart of Brooklyn.

You might be interested in Pizzerias in these nearby locations

4 Tips for Eating Pizza in Flatbush

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. Is Flatbush known for a specific style of pizza?

2. What is Caribbean fusion pizza?

3. How close is the famous Di Fara Pizza?

4. Are there good sit-down pizza restaurants in Flatbush?

5. Where can I find sourdough pizza here?

6. Is it safe to explore Flatbush at night for dinner?

7. Can I get a classic New York slice near the subway?

8. Do these pizzerias offer vegan options?

9. How do I get to Flatbush from Manhattan?

10. Do local pizzerias deliver to Prospect Park?

Ranking: 10 Best Pizzerias in Flatbush

1. ZuriLee Pizza Bar

2. Wheated

3. Di Fara Pizza (nearby)

4. Lo Duca Pizza

5. San Remo Pizzeria

6. Norm’s Pizza (nearby)

7. Antonio’s Pizzeria

8. Gino’s Pizza

9. Pizza Yard (nearby)

10. Pizzeria 33

Explore Our Guides to New York City

Pizzeria Guides

SEO Keywords

10 Best Pizzerias in DUMBO NYC

Niagara Falls Pizza Intelligence Brief — 10 Best Pizzerias (2026 Edition)

Related Articles

The Global Investor Challenge

Are you a Market Master?