Brooklyn Eat & Drink Food & Drink in NYC Locations New York City Pizzerias Pizzerias in New York Restaurants in New York Restaurants in NYC

10 Best Pizzerias in Bay Ridge NYC

Admin_AZ_New_York 1 week ago

68 8 minutes read

10 Best Pizzerias in Bay Ridge NYC

A guide to the top slices and pies in Brooklyn’s classic waterfront neighborhood.

Bay Ridge, nestled in the southwestern corner of Brooklyn under the shadow of the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge, is a neighborhood rich in history and community spirit.

Known for its strong Irish, Norwegian, and Italian-American roots, it boasts beautiful waterfront parks, diverse housing stock from mansions to rowhouses, and bustling commercial strips along 3rd and 5th Avenues filled with local businesses.

The pizza scene in Bay Ridge reflects its heritage: it’s dominated by classic, old-school Italian-American pizzerias and slice shops that have served the community for generations. This is the heartland of the traditional Brooklyn slice, square pies, and hearty Italian dinners where pizza is often the star. Expect quality, consistency, and a warm neighborhood welcome.

This guide, a special curation by AZ New York, is your essential map to the best pizza in this enduring Brooklyn enclave.

“Visão é saber transformar a história de um imóvel em valor presente.”

Você pode se interessar por Pizzarias nestes locais próximos

Location	Est. # of Pizzerias	Distance (from 86th St R Station)
Sunset Park	Diverse options	~1.5 miles
Dyker Heights	Neighborhood spots	~1.0 miles
Bensonhurst	Old School Italian	~1.5 miles
Bath Beach	Neighborhood spots	~2.0 miles
Staten Island (via Bridge)	Island Icons	~2.0 miles (to bridge start)
Fort Hamilton	Limited options	~1.0 miles

Pizzeria Guides in Neighboring Areas

4 Tips for Eating Pizza in Bay Ridge

Third Avenue is Pizza Central: The main commercial artery, 3rd Avenue, is lined with numerous classic pizzerias and Italian restaurants serving great pies. Start your exploration here.
Embrace the Old School: Bay Ridge excels at the traditional. Look for long-standing neighborhood spots known for classic NY slices, Sicilian squares, and Grandma pies.
Verrazzano Views: Grab a slice from a spot near Shore Road and enjoy it in one of the waterfront parks (like Shore Park or Owl’s Head Park) with stunning views of the bridge and the harbor.
Beyond the Slice Shop: Many of Bay Ridge’s best Italian restaurants also serve excellent pizzas as part of their larger menus. Don’t hesitate to order a pie at a sit-down trattoria.

Visão é saber transformar a história de um imóvel em valor presente.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What kind of pizza is Bay Ridge known for?

Bay Ridge is primarily known for classic, traditional New York-style pizza, Sicilian pies, and Grandma slices, often served by long-standing, family-run Italian-American pizzerias.

Is Bay Ridge easy to get to?

The R subway line runs directly through Bay Ridge, with several stops including Bay Ridge Ave, 77th St, 86th St, and Bay Ridge–95th St, making it easily accessible from other parts of Brooklyn and Manhattan. Several bus lines also serve the area.

Are there any modern or Neapolitan pizzerias in Bay Ridge?

While the scene is dominated by classic spots, newer places and some traditional restaurants do offer Neapolitan or wood-fired options, though they are less common than the quintessential NY slice shop. Artichoke Basille’s also has an outpost here.

Ranking: 10 Best Pizzerias in Bay Ridge

Abaixo, confira o ranking das 10 melhores pizzarias da região, em uma curadoria especial da AZ New York.

1. Pizza Wagon

An absolute Bay Ridge institution. This no-frills, standing-room-only spot has been serving textbook-perfect, thin-crust NY slices for decades. Known for its incredible consistency and classic flavor. Cash only often preferred.
Address: 8610 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209
Phone: (718) 836-5725
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: Not Available
Distance: Approx. 0.3 miles from 86th St Station.
Must-Try Slices: Classic Cheese Slice, Pepperoni Slice.

2. Nino’s Pizza

Another long-standing neighborhood cornerstone, Nino’s is beloved for its classic NY slices, squares, and consistently delicious Italian-American fare. A true family-run Bay Ridge staple.
Address: 9110 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209
Phone: (718) 680-0808
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: ninospizzabayridge.com
Distance: Approx. 0.4 miles from 95th St Station.
Must-Try Slices: Cheese Slice, Sicilian Slice, Grandma Slice.

3. Espresso Pizza

A popular local spot known for its solid classic slices and reliable quality. It’s a go-to for many residents for a quick slice or a full pie delivery.
Address: 9403 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209
Phone: (718) 833-0008
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: Not Available (Order via SliceLife, etc.)
Distance: Approx. 0.3 miles from 95th St Station.
Must-Try Slices: Cheese Slice, Pepperoni Slice.

4. Gino’s Restaurant & Pizzeria

A Bay Ridge classic since 1964, Gino’s is a full-service Italian restaurant that also serves fantastic, slightly thicker-crusted pizzas alongside its traditional entrees.
Address: 7414 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209
Phone: (718) 748-1698
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: ginosbayridge.com
Distance: Approx. 0.5 miles from Bay Ridge Ave Station.
Must-Try Pies: Classic Cheese Pie, Gino’s Special.

5. Artichoke Basille’s Pizza (Bay Ridge)

The Bay Ridge outpost of the famous Manhattan chain, bringing its over-the-top, decadent slices like the signature Artichoke slice to southern Brooklyn.
Address: 9202 4th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209
Phone: (718) 833-0300
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: artichokepizza.com
Distance: Approx. 0.2 miles from 95th St Station.
Must-Try Slices: Artichoke Slice, Crab Slice, Vodka Sicilian.

6. Leo’s Casa Calamari

Another neighborhood Italian restaurant known for its seafood (as the name suggests) but also serving reliable and tasty pizzas in a classic setting.
Address: 8602 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209
Phone: (718) 921-1900
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: leoscasacalamari.com
Distance: Approx. 0.1 miles from 86th St Station.
Must-Try Pies: Margherita, Clam Pie.

7. Rocco’s Pizzeria

A popular and highly-rated spot known for quality ingredients, great sauce, and well-executed classic NY and specialty pies. Offers both slices and whole pies.
Address: 7818 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209
Phone: (718) 745-8300
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: roccos-pizzeria.com
Distance: Approx. 0.2 miles from 77th St Station.
Must-Try Slices/Pies: Margherita Slice, Buffalo Chicken Pizza.

8. Vesuvio Restaurant & Pizzeria

A long-standing Italian restaurant serving Bay Ridge since 1953. Vesuvio offers classic red-sauce dishes and dependable, traditional pizzas in a family-friendly atmosphere.
Address: 7305 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209
Phone: (718) 745-0222
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: vesuviobayridge.com
Distance: Approx. 0.3 miles from Bay Ridge Ave Station.
Must-Try Pies: Classic Cheese Pie, Vesuvio Special.

9. Campania Coal Fired Pizza

While primarily known for its Staten Island locations, Campania has an outpost offering coal-fired pies with that signature char and crispness, adding another style to the neighborhood mix.
Address: 9824 4th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209
Phone: (718) 745-4600
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: campaniacoalfiredpizza.com
Distance: Approx. 0.6 miles from 95th St Station.
Must-Try Pies: Margherita, The Campania (Meatballs, Ricotta).

10. Nonno’s Pizza

A solid neighborhood choice offering a wide variety of classic NY slices, specialty pies, rolls, and calzones. Known for generous toppings and friendly service.
Address: 8016 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209
Phone: (718) 833-3113
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: nonnospizza3rdave.com
Distance: Approx. 0.2 miles from 77th St Station.
Must-Try Slices: Grandma Slice, Buffalo Chicken Slice.

All research and the final selection of the pizzerias in this guide were carried out by the team at AZ New York.

Explore Our Guides to New York City

Pizzeria Guides

For insights into another global city’s iconic public squares, you can also explore the complete guide to Praça da Sé in São Paulo.

SEO Keywords

best pizza Bay Ridge, Pizza Wagon Bay Ridge, Nino’s Pizza Bay Ridge, Brooklyn pizza guide, old school Brooklyn pizza, 3rd Ave Bay Ridge, pizza near Verrazzano Bridge, Gino’s Bay Ridge, Espresso Pizza, best slice Bay Ridge, South Brooklyn pizza.