Pizzerias in New York Eat & Drink Food & Drink in NYC Locations Manhattan New York City Pizzerias Restaurants in New York Restaurants in NYC

10 Best Pizzerias near Penn Station & MSG NYC

Admin_AZ_New_York March 1, 2026

198 10 minutes read

10 Best Pizzerias near Penn Station & MSG NYC

86 / 100

SEO Score

Table of Contents

10 Best Pizzerias near Penn Station & MSG NYC

A guide to the ultimate commuter slices and pre-game pies surrounding the busiest transit hub in the Western Hemisphere.

Penn Station and the directly adjacent Madison Square Garden (MSG) form a colossal epicenter of transit, sports, and entertainment in Midtown West, Manhattan. Located approximately 1.2 miles directly south of New York City’s official ground zero at Columbus Circle, this immediate area processes over 600,000 commuters daily, alongside tens of thousands of fans attending Knicks games, Rangers games, and global concerts.

When analyzing the specific pizzeria segment in the immediate blocks surrounding Penn Station and MSG, there are an estimated 30 dedicated pizza establishments. This heavy density is born out of absolute necessity. The market here is ruthlessly efficient, designed to feed hurried Amtrak, NJ Transit, and LIRR riders with lightning speed.

While the avenues are dotted with massive corporate chains and cheap dollar-slice joints, the area also famously harbors one of the most highly respected, critically acclaimed independent slice shops in the entire city, standing as a beacon for true pizza aficionados amidst the commuter chaos.

This guide, a special curation by AZ New York, is your essential map to the best pizza near Penn Station and MSG.

“Feel the incentive to grab a legendary commuter slice before your train, while practicing prudence by keeping a close eye on the Amtrak and NJ Transit departure boards.”

You might be interested in Pizzerias in these nearby locations

Location	Est. # of Pizzerias	Distance (from MSG)
Chelsea	Artisan & Square	~0.4 miles
Hudson Yards	Upscale & Trendy	~0.5 miles
Hell’s Kitchen	Wood Fired & Slices	~0.6 miles
Times Square	Icons & Tourist Spots	~0.6 miles
Flatiron District	Neapolitan & Fast Casual	~0.5 miles
34th Street (Herald Sq)	Quick Commuter Eats	~0.2 miles

Pizzeria Guides in Neighboring Areas

4 Tips for Eating Pizza near Penn Station & MSG

The NY Pizza Suprema Mandate: If you are within a five-block radius of Penn Station, going to NY Pizza Suprema on 8th Avenue is practically mandatory. It consistently ranks as one of the best classic slices in Manhattan and is an absolute oasis of quality in a busy transit zone.
Eat Before You Enter MSG: Food inside Madison Square Garden is notoriously expensive. Grab a high-quality slice or a sit-down pie in the surrounding blocks on 7th or 8th Avenue before going through security to save money and eat vastly better pizza.
Navigate the In-Station Options: If you literally have five minutes before your track is called, Rosa’s Pizza inside the LIRR concourse of Penn Station is a massive step up from standard fast-food terminal fare.
Dodge the Dollar Slices: The blocks immediately north of Penn Station feature numerous “99-cent” (now usually $1.50) slice signs. Unless it is 3:00 AM and you are on a strict budget, walk an extra block to a reputable shop to avoid cardboard crust and low-grade cheese.

“Let the energy of game day at Madison Square Garden incentivize your pre-show dining, but act with prudence by navigating the chaotic crowds along 8th Avenue carefully.”

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. Is NY Pizza Suprema really that good?

Yes. Despite its unassuming storefront right next to the station, it has garnered legendary status among locals, chefs, and critics for serving a flawless, sweet-sauced classic New York slice since 1964.

2. Can I get a sit-down pizza meal near MSG?

Absolutely. While slice shops dominate, places like Lazzara’s Pizza Cafe and nearby Capizzi offer fantastic sit-down environments perfect for a relaxed pre-game or post-concert dinner.

3. Where can I find pizza actually inside Penn Station?

Rosa’s Pizza is located underground within the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) concourse. It is heavily relied upon by daily commuters for a fast, surprisingly solid slice without leaving the transit hub.

4. Are there any late-night options after a concert at MSG?

Yes. The immediate area caters heavily to post-event crowds. NY Pizza Suprema and Joe’s Pizza on Broadway both stay open late to feed fans exiting the arena.

5. Can I bring a pizza box on my Amtrak or NJ Transit train?

Yes, bringing outside food onto these trains is completely acceptable. Taking a box of fresh New York pizza on your journey back home is a very common commuter tradition.

6. What is the best pizza near the new Moynihan Train Hall?

Moynihan Train Hall sits directly across 8th Avenue from MSG. Exiting the hall puts you literally steps away from NY Pizza Suprema, making it the perfect immediate dining option.

7. Is it safe to walk around Penn Station at night?

The areas immediately surrounding MSG and Penn Station are heavily policed and extremely busy during event nights and commuter hours. As with any major transit hub, stay alert, but it is generally very safe for dining.

8. Do they sell Detroit or square style pizza nearby?

Yes. Lazzara’s Pizza Cafe is famous for its thin, square pies, and just south in Chelsea, Lions & Tigers & Squares serves authentic Detroit-style pizza.

9. Are there vegan pizza options near MSG?

Upside Pizza on 8th Avenue offers modern, high-quality ingredients and can accommodate dietary preferences, while classic shops will readily make a cheeseless vegetable pie if requested.

10. What is the average price of a slice here?

Because of the prime Midtown location and captive transit audience, a high-quality plain cheese slice will typically cost between $4.00 and $5.00.

Ranking: 10 Best Pizzerias near Penn Station & MSG

Below, check out the ranking of the 10 best pizzerias immediately surrounding the transit hub, in a special curation by AZ New York.

1. NY Pizza Suprema

The undisputed king of Penn Station dining. Family-owned since 1964, they offer a benchmark classic New York slice with a uniquely sweet sauce and a flawlessly executed Upside Down Sicilian slice.
Address: 413 8th Ave, New York, NY 10001
Phone: (212) 594-8939
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: nypizzasuprema.com
Must-Try Slices: The Upside Down Slice, Regular Cheese Slice.

2. Bleecker Street Pizza (7th Ave)

Located perfectly on 7th Avenue right next to MSG. This outpost of the legendary West Village spot serves their famous “Nonna Maria” slice, a Tuscan-style thin square that is incredibly flavorful.
Address: 368 7th Ave, New York, NY 10001
Phone: (212) 695-0255
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: bleeckerstreetpizza.com
Must-Try Slices: Nonna Maria Slice, Classic Pepperoni.

3. Upside Pizza

Situated slightly north on 8th Avenue, Upside utilizes a naturally fermented sourdough starter and top-tier ingredients to create a highly digestible, modern, and incredibly crispy New York slice.
Address: 598 8th Ave, New York, NY 10018
Phone: (646) 484-5244
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: upsidepizza.com
Must-Try Slices: The Mushroom Slice, Classic Cheese.

4. Lazzara’s Pizza Cafe

A hidden gem located in the Garment District just a few blocks north of MSG. It is a cozy, old-school sit-down restaurant famous for its unique, thin, square-cut pies baked in well-seasoned pans.
Address: 221 W 38th St, New York, NY 10018
Phone: (212) 944-7792
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: lazzaraspizza.com
Must-Try Pies: The Square Cheese Pie.

5. Rosa’s Pizza (Inside Penn Station)

For those who cannot leave the terminal, Rosa’s in the LIRR concourse is a lifesaver. Originally from Queens, they offer a very robust, thick, and satisfying slice that fuels thousands of commuters daily.
Address: Penn Station (LIRR Concourse), New York, NY 10001
Phone: Not available directly.
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: Not available.
Must-Try Slices: Sicilian Square, Chicken Parm Slice.

6. Little Italy Pizza (33rd St)

A classic, fast-paced slice joint located directly across from Madison Square Garden. It is built for sheer volume, providing massive, hot, heavily cheesed slices to pre-game crowds in minutes.
Address: 401 7th Ave (at 33rd St), New York, NY 10001
Phone: (212) 736-0005
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: Not available.
Must-Try Slices: Jumbo Cheese Slice, Sausage Slice.

7. Joe’s Pizza (Broadway)

A short, easy walk from Penn Station towards Times Square. It offers the flawless, legendary Greenwich Village street slice experience for commuters willing to walk just a few extra blocks.
Address: 1435 Broadway, New York, NY 10018
Phone: (646) 559-4878
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: joespizzanyc.com
Must-Try Slices: Plain Cheese Slice, Fresh Mozzarella Slice.

8. Capizzi (nearby)

Located just a short walk northwest into Hell’s Kitchen. This highly authentic spot uses a wood-burning oven to create spectacular Neapolitan pies, offering a refined, sit-down contrast to the transit slice shops.
Address: 547 9th Ave, New York, NY 10018
Phone: (212) 695-6900
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: capizzinyc.com
Must-Try Pies: The Margherita, Roasted Eggplant Pie.

9. Lions & Tigers & Squares (nearby)

Situated just a few blocks south in Chelsea, this is a fantastic post-MSG walk. They specialize entirely in highly authentic, thick, crispy-edged Detroit-style square pizzas that are deeply satisfying.
Address: 268 W 23rd St, New York, NY 10011
Phone: (917) 261-6772
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: Not available.
Must-Try Pies: Classic Detroit Square, Vodka Sauce Square.

10. Carnegie Pizza

Located a short walk north toward Bryant Park, this modern establishment delivers exceptionally clean, crisp New York slices and excellent square pies, making it a great pre-Amtrak option.
Address: 200 W 41st St, New York, NY 10036
Phone: (212) 777-4141
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: carnegiepizza.com
Must-Try Slices: Vodka Square Slice, Plain Cheese.

All research and the final selection of the pizzerias in this guide were carried out by the team at AZ New York.

Explore Our Guides to New York City

Special Location Guides

Legal Notice: The information presented in this guide is based on research conducted in February 2026 and may be subject to changes in hours, prices, and availability. AZ New York has no direct commercial relationship with the establishments mentioned, acting solely as an informative guide.

SEO Keywords

best pizza Penn Station, pizza near Madison Square Garden, NY Pizza Suprema, Bleecker Street Pizza 7th Ave, Upside Pizza 8th Ave, Lazzaras Pizza Cafe, Rosas Pizza Penn Station, pre game food MSG, authentic NY slice Midtown, Moynihan Train Hall pizza, late night pizza MSG, distance to Columbus Circle NYC,

top rated pizzerias Manhattan, NYC commuter food, Amtrak pizza NYC, best slice near Penn Station, artisan pizza Midtown, NYC food tours, quick lunch Midtown West, Italian food Garment District, pizza near Hudson Yards, historic NYC transit dining, Manhattan slice shop, Detroit style pizza Chelsea, NYC tourist pizza guide

1000 Best Pizzerias in New York

NYC Pizzeria Financial Engine

Authorship by AZNewYork.com

1. Monthly Fixed Costs (Burn Rate)

Base Rent + NNN

Labor (Chefs/Staff)

Energy & Gas (Ovens)

Insurance & Licensing

2. Sales Mix Strategy

Slices (High Volume): 70% Pies (High Ticket): 30%

3. COGS & Operational Waste

Ingredients (COGS) (%)

Daily Waste & Spoilage (%)

Tax & Merchant Fees (%)

Breakeven Monthly Revenue

$ 0.00

Monthly sales needed for operational survival.

Fixed Costs

$ 0.00

Daily Goal

$ 0.00

Initializing pizza data...

86 / 100

SEO Score

10 Best Pizzerias near Penn Station & MSG NYC

A guide to the ultimate commuter slices and pre-game pies surrounding the busiest transit hub in the Western Hemisphere.

You might be interested in Pizzerias in these nearby locations

4 Tips for Eating Pizza near Penn Station & MSG

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. Is NY Pizza Suprema really that good?

2. Can I get a sit-down pizza meal near MSG?

3. Where can I find pizza actually inside Penn Station?

4. Are there any late-night options after a concert at MSG?

5. Can I bring a pizza box on my Amtrak or NJ Transit train?

6. What is the best pizza near the new Moynihan Train Hall?

7. Is it safe to walk around Penn Station at night?

8. Do they sell Detroit or square style pizza nearby?

9. Are there vegan pizza options near MSG?

10. What is the average price of a slice here?

Ranking: 10 Best Pizzerias near Penn Station & MSG

1. NY Pizza Suprema

2. Bleecker Street Pizza (7th Ave)

3. Upside Pizza

4. Lazzara’s Pizza Cafe

5. Rosa’s Pizza (Inside Penn Station)

6. Little Italy Pizza (33rd St)

7. Joe’s Pizza (Broadway)

8. Capizzi (nearby)

9. Lions & Tigers & Squares (nearby)

10. Carnegie Pizza

Explore Our Guides to New York City

Special Location Guides

SEO Keywords

NYC Pizzeria Financial Engine

10 Best Pizzerias Near Me in NYC

10 Best Pizzerias near World Trade Center NYC

Related Articles

The Global Investor Challenge

Are you a Market Master?