Syracuse Eat & Drink Food & Drink in NYC Locations New York City Pizzerias Pizzerias in New York Restaurants in New York Restaurants in NYC

10 Best Pizzerias in Syracuse, NY — 2026 Guide

Admin_AZ_New_York 16 hours ago

0 76 4 minutes read

10 Best Pizzerias in Syracuse, NY — 2026 Guide

74 / 100

SEO Score

Table of Contents

10 Best Pizzerias in Syracuse, NY — 2026 Guide

Syracuse, NY is one of Central New York’s most dynamic food cities, known for its university influence, strong regional dining culture, and distinctive pizza preferences. Located approximately 250 miles from New York City, Syracuse sits within a 4.5–5 hour drive, making it a relevant stop for road-trip culinary exploration across New York State.

📊 Estimated Number of Pizzerias in Syracuse

Based on restaurant directories and mapping platforms, Syracuse hosts an estimated 50+ pizza-focused establishments, ranging from independent neighborhood shops to regional institutions and modern artisan kitchens. The density reflects strong local demand driven by residential neighborhoods and student populations.

📊 Comparative Table — Top 10 Pizza Spots in Syracuse (2026)

Rank	Pizzeria	Avg Rating*	Phone	Website	Core Strength
1	Pastabilities / Apizza Regionale	≈ 4.6 / 5	+1 315-474-1153	https://www.pastabilities.com	Artisan & Neapolitan influence
2	Twin Trees Too	≈ 4.5 / 5	+1 315-488-1300	https://www.twintrees.com	Classic Syracuse-style pies
3	Pavone’s Pizza	≈ 4.4 / 5	+1 315-475-0000	https://www.pavonespizza.com	Reliable local staple
4	Varsity Pizza	≈ 4.3 / 5	+1 315-446-1010	http://varsitypizza.com	Strong student following
5	OIP (Original Italian Pizza)	≈ 4.2 / 5	+1 315-478-0000	(no unified official site)	Regional consistency
6	Mario & Salvo’s Pizzeria	≈ 4.5 / 5	+1 315-479-9255	https://marioandsalvos.com	Large slices & classic execution
7	Peppino’s Neapolitan	≈ 4.4 / 5	+1 315-422-0000	http://peppinospizzeria.com	Traditional flavor profile
8	Paladino’s Pizzeria	≈ 4.3 / 5	+1 315-469-1919	https://paladinospizza.com	Neighborhood loyalty favorite
9	Nick’s Tomato Pie	≈ 4.5 / 5	+1 315-488-0000	(local presence)	Regional-style comfort pizza
10	Francesca’s Pizza & Italian Kitchen	≈ 4.2 / 5	+1 315-478-9700	https://francescaspizzeria.com	Balanced traditional pies

*Avg Rating reflects blended cross-platform review patterns (Google Maps + review ecosystems). Ratings fluctuate dynamically.

🍕 3 Real Pizza Scenarios in Syracuse

1️⃣ University-Driven Slice Economy

Syracuse University strongly shapes pizza demand patterns. Large slices, extended hours, and fast service dominate high-traffic zones.

2️⃣ Regional Texture Preference

Compared with NYC, Syracuse pizza often trends slightly thicker with heavier cheese distribution — a regional comfort-food bias.

3️⃣ Artisan Pizza Expansion

Apizza Regionale illustrates Syracuse’s growing appreciation for fermentation precision and Neapolitan-inspired techniques.

❓ FAQ — Syracuse Pizza Insights

1. Does Syracuse have a distinct pizza identity?
Yes — regional preferences often favor thicker crust and richer cheese coverage.

2. Are slices or whole pies more common?
Slice culture is strong, especially near university districts.

3. Why are slices often larger?
Student demand and value perception influence portion sizing.

4. Is Syracuse pizza similar to NYC pizza?
Influenced by NYC, but structurally different in crust and density.

5. Are artisan pizzerias common?
Increasingly present within the dining ecosystem.

6. Does oven type vary?
Primarily gas/deck ovens, with selective artisan ovens.

7. Is pizza affordable in Syracuse?
Generally more accessible than major metro markets.

8. Does Syracuse favor specialty toppings?
Yes — specialty pies remain popular.

9. How many pizzerias exist locally?
Estimated 50+ pizza establishments across the metro area.

10. Best time for fresh pizza?
Peak lunch and evening hours.

🔎 Curiosities & Expert Notes

Syracuse maintains strong pizza density relative to city size.
Large-slice format is a regional behavioral adaptation.
Student populations heavily influence late-night demand.
Artisan fermentation trends continue expanding.

🏷️ Tags

best pizza Syracuse NY, Syracuse pizzerias, top pizza Syracuse, Syracuse pizza guide, pizza restaurants Syracuse, Syracuse slices, Apizza Regionale, Twin Trees Syracuse, Pavone’s Pizza, Varsity Pizza Syracuse, Syracuse food scene, Syracuse dining guide, where to eat pizza Syracuse, Syracuse pizza ranking, artisan pizza Syracuse, classic pizza Syracuse, late-night pizza Syracuse, Central New York pizza, pizza lovers Syracuse

74 / 100

SEO Score

Opening a Cocktail Bar in Manhattan: Startup Costs and License Guide

How is the rise of fintech and cryptocurrencies challenging the traditional financial dominance of Wall Street?

The “Secret” Floor at Saks Only VIPs Can Access

10 Best Veterinary Hospitals in White Plains NY

The Real Cost of Opening a Restaurant in NYC: 2026 Financial Blueprint

Madison Avenue Shopping Guide

Style, Innovation & Culture: How New York Brands Shape Global Lifestyle

A Guide to Parking in Manhattan

Complete Guide: The 10 Best Gas Stations in Rockland County, NY | Guide

NYC Ultimate Black Friday Shopping List

10 Best Pizzerias in Syracuse, NY — 2026 Guide

10 Best Pizzerias in Syracuse, NY — 2026 Guide

📊 Estimated Number of Pizzerias in Syracuse

📊 Comparative Table — Top 10 Pizza Spots in Syracuse (2026)