10 Best Pizzerias in Rochester, NY — 2026 Guide
10 Best Pizzerias in Rochester, NY — 2026 Guide
Rochester, NY has quietly developed one of the most interesting pizza scenes in Upstate New York. Blending classic New York influences with strong regional favorites, the city offers everything from traditional thin slices to deeply indulgent specialty pies. This guide highlights establishments consistently recognized for quality, reputation, and customer satisfaction.
📊 Comparative Table — Top 10 Pizza Spots in Rochester (2026)
| Rank | Pizzeria | Avg Rating* | Phone | Website | Core Strength |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Pizza Stop | ≈ 4.6 / 5 | +1 585-546-7250 | https://www.pizzastoponline.com | Classic NYC-style slices |
| 2 | Peels on Wheels | ≈ 4.7 / 5 | +1 585-413-0503 | https://www.peelsonwheels.com | Artisan wood-fired pizzas |
| 3 | Salvatore’s Old Fashioned Pizzeria | ≈ 4.4 / 5 | +1 585-663-3430 | https://www.salvatores.com | Local favorite & consistency |
| 4 | Cam’s Pizzeria | ≈ 4.3 / 5 | +1 585-271-2267 | https://www.camspizzeria.com | Reliable slice shop experience |
| 5 | Mark’s Pizzeria | ≈ 4.2 / 5 | +1 585-247-2220 | https://www.markspizzeria.com | Well-known regional chain |
| 6 | Ken’s Pizza Corner | ≈ 4.5 / 5 | +1 585-544-8470 | http://www.kenspizzacorner.com | Neighborhood classic |
| 7 | Joe’s Brooklyn Pizza | ≈ 4.6 / 5 | +1 585-424-2150 | https://www.joesbrooklynpizza.com | Authentic Brooklyn-style pies |
| 8 | Guidas Pizzeria | ≈ 4.4 / 5 | +1 585-244-3210 | https://www.guidas.com | Traditional Rochester staple |
| 9 | Create A Pizza | ≈ 4.3 / 5 | +1 585-482-0000 | http://createapizzany.com | Custom-built pizza concept |
| 10 | Pudgie’s Pizza | ≈ 4.2 / 5 | +1 585-247-9999 | https://www.pudgiespizza.com | Regional comfort pizza |
*Avg Rating reflects blended cross-platform review patterns (Google Maps + customer review ecosystems). Ratings fluctuate dynamically.
🍕 3 Real Pizza Scenarios in Rochester
1️⃣ Downtown Slice Reliability
High-turnover slice shops like Pizza Stop benefit from constant oven cycling. Rapid pie replacement improves crust texture consistency and cheese melt behavior.
2️⃣ Artisan Pizza Expansion
Peels on Wheels represents Rochester’s growing appetite for fermentation-driven dough, wood-fired blistering, and ingredient-forward compositions.
3️⃣ Regional Loyalty Effect
Longstanding names like Salvatore’s and Guidas demonstrate how neighborhood familiarity often outweighs trend-driven dining behavior.
❓ FAQ — Rochester Pizza Insights
1. Does Rochester have a distinct pizza style?
Rochester blends NYC thin-crust influence with thicker regional comfort styles.
2. Are slices common or whole pies preferred?
Both thrive — slice culture is strong near downtown zones.
3. Is artisan pizza popular in Rochester?
Increasingly. Wood-fired and craft dough concepts continue expanding.
4. Why do some pizzas feel sweeter?
Sauce formulation and sugar balance vary widely across establishments.
5. Are regional chains dominant?
Yes, though independent shops maintain strong loyalty.
6. Does oven type vary much?
Mostly gas and deck ovens, with growing wood-fired presence.
7. Is pizza affordable in Rochester?
Generally more accessible than major metro markets.
8. Best time for fresh slices?
Peak lunch & evening turnover hours.
9. Are specialty toppings common?
Yes — many shops emphasize custom combinations.
10. What defines a great Rochester pizza experience?
Balance of crust structure, sauce profile, and topping restraint.
🔎 Curiosities & Expert Notes
- Rochester maintains strong slice-shop culture relative to city size.
- Fermentation-forward artisan pizza continues expanding locally.
- Regional chains coexist with deeply rooted independent shops.
- Texture preferences vary widely among local consumers.
🏷️ Tags
best pizza Rochester NY, Rochester pizzerias, top pizza Rochester, Rochester pizza guide, pizza restaurants Rochester, Rochester slices, artisan pizza Rochester, wood-fired pizza Rochester, Rochester food scene, Pizza Stop Rochester, Peels on Wheels, Salvatore’s Pizzeria, Cam’s Pizzeria, Joe’s Brooklyn Pizza, Guidas Pizzeria, Ken’s Pizza Corner, Pudgie’s Pizza, Rochester dining guide, Rochester eats, pizza lovers Rochester, where to eat pizza Rochester, Rochester pizza ranking, Upstate NY pizza
10 Best Pizzerias in Alphabet City NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Arthur Avenue (Bronx) NYC
The 8 Best Artichoke Pizza Locations in NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Astoria NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Battery Park City NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Bay Ridge NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Bed-Stuy NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Bensonhurst NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Boerum Hill NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Brooklyn Heights NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Bushwick NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Carroll Gardens NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Chelsea NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Chinatown NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Clinton Hill NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Cobble Hill NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Coney Island NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Crown Heights NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in DUMBO NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in the East Village NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in the Financial District (FiDi) NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Flatbush NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in the Flatiron District NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Flushing NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Fordham NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Forest Hills NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Fort Greene NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in the Garment District NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Gowanus NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Gramercy Park NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Greenpoint NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Greenwich Village NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Harlem NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Hell’s Kitchen NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Inwood NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Jackson Heights NYC
The 5 Best Joe’s Pizza Locations in NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Kips Bay NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Long Island City NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in the Lower East Side NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in the Meatpacking District NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Midtown NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Midtown East NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Morningside Heights NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Murray Hill NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in NoLita NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Park Slope NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Prospect Heights NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Red Hook NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Ridgewood NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Riverdale NYC
The 5 Best Roberta’s Pizza Locations in NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Sheepshead Bay NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in SoHo NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Staten Island NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Sunset Park NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Sunnyside NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in TriBeCa NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Two Bridges NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Union Square NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in the Upper East Side NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in the Upper West Side NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Washington Heights NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in the West Village NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Williamsburg NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Woodside NYC
