10 Best Pizzerias in Buffalo, NY — 2026 Guide
10 Best Pizzerias in Buffalo, NY — 2026 Guide
Buffalo is not only famous for its wings — the region also boasts an energetic pizza scene with a blend of classic, New York-inspired, and locally beloved styles. From artisan Neapolitan interpretations to hearty local favorites, this guide highlights the most acclaimed pizzerias based on reviews, reputation, and local culture. :contentReference[oaicite:0]{index=0}
📊 Comparative Table — Top 10 Pizza Spots in Buffalo (2026)
| Rank | Pizzeria | Avg Rating* | Phone | Website | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ≈ 4.9/5 | +1 716-248-2240 | https://bflopizzabistro.com/ | Highly rated bistro-style pizza | |
| 2 | ≈ 4.7/5 | +1 716-248-2994 | https://www.extraextrapizza.com/ | Buffalo soul pizza classic | |
| 3 | ≈ 4.8/5 | +1 716-636-9500 | http://fornonapoliny.com/ | Authentic Neapolitan style | |
| 4 | ≈ 4.6/5 | (no local phone) | http://www.jaysbuffalo.com/ | Award-recognized artisan pizzas | |
| 5 | ≈ 4.4/5 | +1 716-883-2323 | http://www.lovejoypizza.com/ | Classic Buffalo-area favorite | |
| 6 | ≈ 4.5/5 | +1 716-844-8496 | http://www.brickovendeli.com/ | Comfort pizza & deli fusion | |
| 7 | ≈ 4.3/5 | +1 716-836-5411 | https://bobandjohns.com/ | Neighborhood classic | |
| 8 | ≈ 4.2/5 | +1 716-881-3303 | http://lanova.com/ | Historic Buffalo staple | |
| 9 | ≈ 4.6/5 | +1 716-810-1005 | https://nakedcitylv.com/buffalo | Great Buffalo-area pizza | |
| 10 |
|
≈ 4.2/5 | +1 716-883-8200 | http://casadipizza.com/ | Local favorite with long reviews |
🍕 3 Pizza Stories from Buffalo
1️⃣ Cup & Char Culture
Buffalo’s pizza often features “cup & char” pepperoni where the edges curl up and hold flavorful oil pools — a regional signature beloved by locals. :contentReference[oaicite:11]{index=11}
2️⃣ Jay’s Artisan Recognition
Jay’s Artisan Pizza earned national attention from global rankings, noting Buffalo in the top U.S. pizzeria lists and showcasing Neapolitan and Detroit-style influence. :contentReference[oaicite:12]{index=12}
3️⃣ Classic Trail Favorites
The Buffalo Pizza Trail includes historic names like Bocce Club and Santora’s, reflecting local evolution from thick, cheese-heavy pies to more balanced modern styles. :contentReference[oaicite:13]{index=13}
❓ FAQ — Buffalo Pizza Insights
1. What defines Buffalo pizza style?
Often thicker crust with sweet sauce and charred pepperoni “cups”. :contentReference[oaicite:14]{index=14}
2. Is Buffalo pizza similar to New York pizza?
No — Buffalo balances between classic and regional thickness, differing from thin NYC slices. :contentReference[oaicite:15]{index=15}
3. Are there Neapolitan options here?
Yes — places like Forno Napoli bring traditional Neapolitan techniques. :contentReference[oaicite:16]{index=16}
4. Can you find award-winning pizza in Buffalo?
Jay’s Artisan Pizza has earned national pizza rankings. :contentReference[oaicite:17]{index=17}
5. What neighborhood has great pizza?
Elmwood and Hertel avenues host many beloved pizzerias. :contentReference[oaicite:18]{index=18}
6. Best pizza for delivery?
Extra Extra and Bflo Pizza Bistro both have strong delivery reputations. :contentReference[oaicite:19]{index=19}
7. Is Buffalo pizza kid-friendly?
Many local spots are casual and family-friendly. :contentReference[oaicite:20]{index=20}
8. Does Buffalo have thin crust options?
Yes — Naked City and Jay’s offer thin and artisan styles. :contentReference[oaicite:21]{index=21}
9. Are there historic pizzerias?
Yes — La Nova and Bocce Club reflect long-standing local traditions. :contentReference[oaicite:22]{index=22}
10. Best time to visit?
Lunch and evening hours see peak freshness and service. :contentReference[oaicite:23]{index=23}
🔎 Curiosities & Notes
- Buffalo pizza often contrasts NYC style with regional crust and pepperoni patterns. :contentReference[oaicite:24]{index=24}
- Multiple Buffalo spots show up in state wine and travel guides due to unique pizza culture. :contentReference[oaicite:25]{index=25}
- Wood-oven and Neapolitan influences are growing in the area. :contentReference[oaicite:26]{index=26}
🏷️ Tags
best pizza Buffalo, Buffalo pizzerias, top pizza Buffalo NY, Buffalo pizza guide, pizza restaurants Buffalo, Buffalo pizza trail, Neapolitan pizza Buffalo, cup and char pizza, pizza delivery Buffalo, Extra Extra Pizza, Bflo Pizza Bistro, Forno Napoli Buffalo,
Jay’s Artisan Pizza, Lovejoy Pizza, Brick Oven Bistro, JJs Casa Di Pizza, Naked City Pizza, Buffalo dining guide, Buffalo food blog, pizza FAQ Buffalo, Buffalo eats, pizza lovers Buffalo, Buffalo culinary scene
10 Best Pizzerias in Alphabet City NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Arthur Avenue (Bronx) NYC
The 8 Best Artichoke Pizza Locations in NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Astoria NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Battery Park City NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Bay Ridge NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Bed-Stuy NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Bensonhurst NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Boerum Hill NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Brooklyn Heights NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Bushwick NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Carroll Gardens NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Chelsea NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Chinatown NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Clinton Hill NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Cobble Hill NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Coney Island NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Crown Heights NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in DUMBO NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in the East Village NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in the Financial District (FiDi) NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Flatbush NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in the Flatiron District NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Flushing NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Fordham NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Forest Hills NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Fort Greene NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in the Garment District NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Gowanus NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Gramercy Park NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Greenpoint NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Greenwich Village NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Harlem NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Hell’s Kitchen NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Inwood NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Jackson Heights NYC
The 5 Best Joe’s Pizza Locations in NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Kips Bay NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Long Island City NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in the Lower East Side NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in the Meatpacking District NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Midtown NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Midtown East NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Morningside Heights NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Murray Hill NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in NoLita NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Park Slope NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Prospect Heights NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Red Hook NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Ridgewood NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Riverdale NYC
The 5 Best Roberta’s Pizza Locations in NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Sheepshead Bay NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in SoHo NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Staten Island NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Sunset Park NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Sunnyside NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in TriBeCa NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Two Bridges NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Union Square NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in the Upper East Side NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in the Upper West Side NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Washington Heights NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in the West Village NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Williamsburg NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in Woodside NYC
One Comment