The Best Private Schools in Short Hills, NJ & Essex County
The Best Private Schools in Short Hills, NJ & Essex County
New Jersey’s Power Corridor: Elite Academics West of the Hudson
Just a short train ride from Midtown Manhattan, New Jersey’s affluent “commuter belt”—particularly areas like **Short Hills, Summit, and Livingston** in Essex and surrounding counties—boasts its own ecosystem of powerful and prestigious private schools.
These institutions serve families in finance, pharmaceuticals, and law who seek top-tier academics comparable to NYC’s best, but within a suburban New Jersey setting.
The Garden State’s elite schools are known for their **sprawling campuses, strong athletics, and a demanding college-preparatory curriculum**. While perhaps less globally famous than Manhattan’s “Ivy Preps,” schools like Pingry, Delbarton, and Newark Academy are academic heavyweights with impressive Ivy League placement records and fierce local loyalty.
They offer a distinct blend of high achievement and traditional East Coast prep school culture.
“Develop a passion for learning. If you do, you will never cease to grow.” – Anthony J. D’Angelo
| Region | Primary Vibe & Focus |
|---|---|
| The Best Private Schools in Westchester | The NY “Country Day School” Elites |
| The Best Private Schools in Greenwich, CT | Hedge Fund Hub & Elite CT Preps |
| The 10 Best Private Schools in NYC | The Overall Elite View |
| The 10 Best Private Schools in Manhattan | The “Old Guard” Ivy Pipeline |
| Guide to NYC Private School Tiers | Decoding the “Types” of Schools |
Strategic Tips for Navigating NJ Admissions
- Top Public Schools are Fierce Competition: Similar to Westchester, towns like Millburn (home of Short Hills), Summit, and Livingston have some of the highest-ranked public school systems in the nation. The decision between elite public and elite private is a central one for NJ families.
- The “Big Four” Independent Schools: The landscape is largely defined by four major co-ed and single-sex independent schools: **The Pingry School**, **Newark Academy**, **Kent Place School** (girls), and **Montclair Kimberley Academy**. These schools compete fiercely for top students.
- The Catholic Powerhouses: New Jersey also boasts incredibly strong Catholic prep schools, particularly the all-boys **Delbarton School** and **Seton Hall Prep**, which are academic and athletic titans.
- Proximity to Boarding Schools: Northern NJ is strategically located near prestigious Pennsylvania and Connecticut boarding schools (Lawrenceville, Blair, Hotchkiss, Taft). Many families use local K-8 schools as feeders.
The NJ X-Factor: Understated Achievement & Strong Community. While deeply connected to NYC’s economy, NJ’s elite schools often foster a culture that’s less about overt Manhattan prestige and more about rigorous academics, athletic achievement, and deep-rooted community ties within the Garden State.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Are NJ private schools as prestigious as NYC schools?
The top NJ schools (Pingry, Delbarton, Newark Academy, Kent Place) are absolutely considered peers to top NYC schools in terms of academic rigor and college placement. They might have less global name recognition but are powerhouses in their own right, particularly within the Ivy League and elite liberal arts college admissions circuits.
What is the difference between Pingry and Newark Academy?
Both are elite co-ed day schools. Pingry, with campuses in Basking Ridge and Short Hills, is often seen as slightly more traditional and sports-focused, with a legendary “Honor Code.” Newark Academy in Livingston is known for its rigorous academics, strong arts program, and perhaps a slightly more progressive or diverse feel, including offering the IB Diploma.
Are Delbarton and Seton Hall Prep only for Catholic families?
While founded in the Catholic tradition (Benedictine for Delbarton, Archdiocesan for Seton Hall Prep), these schools typically welcome students of various backgrounds, though Catholic families often receive some preference in admissions. The Catholic faith and values are integral to the school culture.
Ranking: The 10 Best Private Schools in the Short Hills Area (Essex, Morris, Union Counties)
This list focuses on the most prestigious and influential independent and Catholic schools serving NYC’s NJ commuter belt.
1. The Pingry School (Basking Ridge/Short Hills)
Highlight: A dominant co-ed K-12 independent school known for its Honor Code, academic rigor, and exceptional athletics.
Justification: Pingry is arguably NJ’s most prestigious non-boarding prep school. Its massive Basking Ridge campus (grades 6-12) and Short Hills campus (K-5) offer unparalleled facilities and a powerful pipeline to top universities.
Phone: (908) 647-5555
Website: pingry.org
2. Delbarton School (Morristown)
Highlight: An elite all-boys Catholic (Benedictine) school (grades 7-12) renowned for academics, athletics, and character development. Offers boarding.
Justification: Delbarton is a NJ institution. It combines top-tier academics with a strong emphasis on faith, community (“Succisa Virescit”), and athletic dominance, particularly in hockey and lacrosse.
Address: 230 Mendham Rd, Morristown, NJ 07960
Phone: (973) 538-3231
Website: delbarton.org
3. Newark Academy (Livingston)
Highlight: A top-tier co-ed independent school (grades 6-12) offering both AP and the IB Diploma Programme. Strong arts.
Justification: Newark Academy provides exceptional academic breadth and depth. Its IB program attracts globally-minded students, and it’s known for its rigorous yet supportive environment.
Address: 91 S Orange Ave, Livingston, NJ 07039
Phone: (973) 992-7000
Website: newarka.edu
4. Kent Place School (Summit)
Highlight: The premier all-girls independent school (Pre-K to 12) in NJ, known for leadership development and STEM focus.
Justification: Kent Place empowers young women through a rigorous curriculum, particularly strong in STEM (its Ethics Institute is renowned), and a commitment to fostering leadership skills.
Address: 42 Norwood Ave, Summit, NJ 07901
Phone: (908) 273-0900
Website: kentplace.org
5. Montclair Kimberley Academy (MKA) (Montclair)
Highlight: A large, co-ed Pre-K to 12 independent school spread across three distinct campuses, known for academics and arts.
Justification: MKA offers a comprehensive education with a strong emphasis on both traditional academics and robust arts programs. Its multiple campuses cater to different age groups.
Address: 201 Valley Rd, Montclair, NJ 07042 (Upper School Campus)
Phone: (973) 746-9800
Website: mka.org
6. Seton Hall Preparatory School (West Orange)
Highlight: The oldest Catholic college prep school in NJ (founded 1856), all-boys (grades 9-12), known for tradition and athletics.
Justification: “The Prep” has a deep history and powerful alumni network. It offers a rigorous Catholic education and is a perennial powerhouse in NJ high school sports.
Address: 120 Northfield Ave, West Orange, NJ 07052
Phone: (973) 736-9300
Website: shp.org
7. Morristown Beard School (Morristown)
Highlight: A co-ed independent school (grades 6-12) known for its innovative curriculum and strong sense of community.
Justification: MoBeard balances traditional prep school rigor with a focus on experiential learning and student well-being, creating a dynamic and supportive environment.
Address: 70 Whippany Rd, Morristown, NJ 07960
Phone: (973) 539-3032
Website: mbs.net
8. Oratory Preparatory School (Summit)
Highlight: An all-boys Catholic school (grades 7-12) focused on small class sizes and personalized attention.
Justification: Oratory Prep provides a rigorous Catholic education within a smaller, more intimate setting compared to Delbarton or Seton Hall, fostering close student-teacher relationships.
Address: 1 Beverly Rd, Summit, NJ 07901
Phone: (908) 273-1084
Website: oratoryprep.org
9. Oak Knoll School of the Holy Child (Summit)
Highlight: An elite Catholic school (Pre-K to 12), co-ed lower school and all-girls upper school. Part of the Holy Child network.
Justification: Oak Knoll offers a seamless Pre-K-12 education grounded in Holy Child values. Its all-girls Upper School is highly regarded for academic excellence and leadership development.
Address: 44 Blackburn Rd, Summit, NJ 07901
Phone: (908) 522-8100
Website: oakknoll.org
10. Far Hills Country Day School (Far Hills)
Highlight: A prestigious Pre-K to 8 independent school known as a key feeder to top boarding and local day high schools.
Justification: Far Hills provides an exceptional foundational education in a beautiful setting. Its mission focuses on preparing younger students for the rigors of elite secondary schools like Pingry, Delbarton, or top boarding schools.
Address: 697 US-202, Far Hills, NJ 07931
Phone: (908) 766-0622
Website: fhcds.org
Check Out Our Other Education Guides
- The Best Private Schools in Westchester County
- The Best Private Schools in Greenwich, CT
- The 10 Best Private Schools in NYC
Keywords for your online search
best private schools nj, short hills private schools, essex county private schools, the pingry school, delbarton school, newark academy, kent place school, montclair kimberley academy, seton hall prep, morristown beard school, oratory prep, oak knoll school, far hills country day school, nj ivy league feeder schools, best private high schools nj, best private elementary schools nj, nj boarding schools, morristown private schools, summit nj private schools, livingston nj private schools, basking ridge schools, nj catholic schools, nj independent schools, nj prep schools, millburn schools comparison.
Back to: The 10 Best Private Schools in NYC
The 10 Best Private Schools in NYC
The 10 Best Universities in New York City
