10 Best Pizzerias in the West Village NYC
10 Best Pizzerias in the West Village NYC
A guide to the cozy pizzerias and artisanal slices of this charming area.
The West Village is the New York City of dreams. With its enchanting tree-lined streets that defy the Manhattan grid, historic brownstones, and intimate, cozy atmosphere, it feels like a true residential oasis. This charming character extends directly to its exceptional pizza scene.
Unlike the punk-rock energy of the East Village or the historic bustle of Greenwich Village, the pizzerias here are often charming, neighborhood-focused spots perfect for a date night or a relaxed meal.
This guide, a special curation by AZ New York, is your map to discovering the best pizza in one of Manhattan’s most beloved neighborhoods.
You might be interested in Pizzerias in these nearby locations
| Location | Est. # of Pizzerias | Distance (from Sheridan Square) |
|---|---|---|
| Greenwich Village | Icons & Legends | ~0.2 miles |
| Chelsea | Neighborhood spots | ~0.8 miles |
| SoHo | Trendy spots | ~0.7 miles |
| Meatpacking District | Upscale Options | ~0.6 miles |
| Union Square | Variety of options | ~0.8 miles |
4 Tips for Eating Pizza in the West Village
- Wander and Discover: The West Village is made for walking. The best experience is to wander its winding streets and discover a charming pizzeria tucked away on a quiet block.
- Ideal for a Date Night: The cozy, intimate, and romantic atmosphere of many West Village pizzerias makes it one of the best neighborhoods in the city for a pizza date.
- Combine with a Park Visit: Grab a slice to go and enjoy it while people-watching at Washington Square Park or find a quiet bench along the Hudson River Park waterfront.
- Reservations for Sit-Down Spots: For the popular sit-down pizzerias, especially on weekends, making a reservation is highly recommended to avoid a long wait.
Keep an Eye On: The Pizzeria as a Neighborhood Hub.
In a quiet, residential area like the West Village, a pizzeria becomes more than just a place to eat. It evolves into a true neighborhood institution, a reliable hub for the local community.
These spots become part of residents’ daily lives—the go-to for a weeknight family dinner, the place to celebrate a small victory, or simply the familiar counter where you know your order by heart.
This deep community connection is what gives these pizzerias their soul, making them beloved beyond just the quality of their food.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What’s the difference between the West Village and Greenwich Village?
Though often used interchangeably, the West Village is technically the western portion of greater Greenwich Village. It’s known for being more residential, quieter, and having more of the charming, non-grid streets, while the central and eastern parts of Greenwich Village are busier and more commercial.
Is the pizza scene in the West Village more casual or upscale?
It’s a perfect mix of both. You’ll find some of the city’s most acclaimed artisanal slice shops for a quick bite, alongside beautiful, sit-down pizzerias that offer a more upscale, full-service dining experience.
Is the West Village expensive for pizza?
It’s in line with other popular downtown Manhattan neighborhoods. While you can find affordable slices, the sit-down restaurants will be a mid-range to upscale dining experience, reflecting the area’s high desirability.
Ranking: 10 Best Pizzerias in the West Village
Below, check out the ranking of the 10 best pizzerias in the region, in a special curation by AZ New York.
1. L’industrie Pizzeria
After conquering Brooklyn, L’industrie opened its West Village location and immediately became a sensation. They are known for using the absolute highest quality ingredients, like imported Italian cheeses and fresh basil, on a perfectly crispy yet light crust.
Address: 104 Christopher St, New York, NY 10014
Phone: (646) 434-5899
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: lindustrienyc.com
Distance: Approx. 0.4 miles from Sheridan Square.
Must-Try Slices: Burrata Slice, Fig Jam & Bacon Slice.
2. John’s of Bleecker Street
A true legend located on the border of the West and Greenwich Villages. This cash-only institution has been serving perfect coal-fired, thin-crust pizzas since 1929. They famously serve only whole pies (no slices).
Address: 278 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014
Phone: (212) 243-1680
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: johnsofbleecker.com
Distance: Approx. 0.3 miles from Sheridan Square.
Must-Try Pies: The “Original” Cheese Pie, The “Boom Pie” (Sausage, Pepperoni, Meatball).
3. Joe’s Pizza
The Carmine Street location is the original and sits right on the edge of the West Village. It’s the undisputed benchmark for the classic NYC slice—perfectly balanced, consistent, and always delicious.
Address: 7 Carmine St, New York, NY 10014
Phone: (212) 366-1182
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: joespizzanyc.com
Distance: Approx. 0.4 miles from Sheridan Square.
Must-Try Slices: Classic Cheese Slice, Fresh Mozzarella Slice.
4. Brunetti
A charming, cozy spot that serves fantastic, authentic Neapolitan pizza from a beautiful wood-fired oven. It’s a hidden gem perfect for a date night, with a great wine list and a warm, inviting atmosphere.
Address: 626 Hudson St, New York, NY 10014
Phone: (212) 255-5573
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: pizzeriabrunetti.com
Distance: Approx. 0.5 miles from Sheridan Square.
Must-Try Pies: Margherita, Vongole (with clams).
5. Bleecker Street Pizza
Located on the border of both villages, this shop is famous for its “Nonna Maria” slice, which uses a family-recipe chunky tomato sauce and fresh mozzarella. It’s a top-tier slice shop with a loyal following.
Address: 69 7th Ave S, New York, NY 10014
Phone: (212) 924-4466
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: bleeckerstreetpizza.com
Distance: Located right at Sheridan Square.
Must-Try Slices: Nonna Maria Slice, Pepperoni Slice.
6. Song E Nàpoli
An incredibly authentic, intimate Neapolitan pizzeria that makes you feel like you’ve been transported to Naples. The husband-and-wife team serves passionate, perfectly crafted pizzas from a stunning wood-fired oven.
Address: 132 W Houston St, New York, NY 10012
Phone: (917) 409-3224
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: songenapoli.com
Distance: Approx. 0.6 miles from Sheridan Square.
Must-Try Pies: Margherita, Diavola.
7. Numero 28 Pizzeria
This location of the Roman-style pizzeria is known for its long, oval-shaped pies meant for sharing. The thin, crispy crust and lively atmosphere make it a great spot for groups.
Address: 28 Carmine St, New York, NY 10014
Phone: (212) 463-9654
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: numero28.com
Distance: Approx. 0.4 miles from Sheridan Square.
Must-Try Pies: Numero 28 (speck, truffle cream, mushrooms), Tartufata.
8. Olio e Più
A beautiful, bustling trattoria with a large sidewalk patio that feels like a European cafe. They serve delicious, rustic Neapolitan-style pizzas from a wood-fired oven alongside a full menu of Italian classics.
Address: 3 Greenwich Ave, New York, NY 10014
Phone: (212) 243-6546
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: olioepiu.nyc
Distance: Approx. 0.3 miles from Sheridan Square.
Must-Try Pies: Margherita, Prosciutto e Fichi (figs).
9. Village Square Pizza
For fans of square slices, this nearby spot is a must. They specialize in Sicilian and pepperoni-cup-covered squares with a light, airy dough and crispy, cheesy edges.
Address: 147 Sullivan St, New York, NY 10012
Phone: (646) 484-5468
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: villagesquarepizza.com
Distance: Approx. 0.6 miles from Sheridan Square.
Must-Try Slices: Pepperoni Square, Vodka Sauce Square.
10. Pizza Loves Emily
A destination pizzeria famous for its Detroit-style pies and an incredible burger. The pizza features a thick, focaccia-like crust with a crispy, cheesy “frico” edge and creative, high-quality toppings.
Address: 35 Downing St, New York, NY 10014
Phone: (917) 935-6180
WhatsApp: Not available.
Site: pizzalovesemily.com
Distance: Approx. 0.5 miles from Sheridan Square.
Must-Try Pies: The Emmy (banana peppers, ranch), The Colony (pepperoni, hot honey).
All research and the final selection of the pizzerias in this guide were carried out by the team at AZ New York.
Explore Our Guides to New York City
Pizzeria Guides
- Chinatown
- East Village
- Greenwich Village
- Lower East Side
- NoLita
- SoHo
- TriBeCa
- West Village
- Williamsburg
For insights into another global city with charming neighborhoods, you can also explore the vintage shops of Vila Madalena, São Paulo.
SEO Keywords
best pizza West Village, L’industrie Pizzeria, Brunetti NYC, where to eat in West Village, NYC pizza guide, Neapolitan pizza, West Village restaurants, John’s of Bleecker, Joe’s Pizza, romantic restaurants NYC, best slice in West Village, New York food guide, authentic NYC pizza, West Village food tour, Christopher Street food, Bleecker Street pizza, what to eat in West Village, Pizza Loves Emily, date night NYC.
🍕 The 25 Best Pizzeria Chains in New York City: Tradition, Flavor, and Innovation
