Complete Guide: The 10 Best Gas Stations in Staten Island, NY
Complete Guide: The 10 Best Gas Stations in Staten Island, NY
By: AZ New York Staff
Staten Island: NYC’s Haven for Cheaper Gas
Often referred to as the “forgotten borough,” Staten Island holds a distinct advantage for drivers: consistently the cheapest gas prices in New York City. Thanks to lower county taxes (Richmond County) and a more suburban layout allowing for larger stations, drivers often cross the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge from Brooklyn or come from New Jersey via the Goethals or Bayonne Bridges specifically to fill up. With approximately 55 stations serving major routes like the Staten Island Expressway (I-278), Richmond Avenue, and Hylan Boulevard, knowing the best spots can lead to significant savings.
| Borough / Area | Approx. Nº of Stations | Approx. Distance (from Central SI) |
|---|---|---|
| Staten Island, NY | ~55 | 0 miles |
| Brooklyn, NY | ~280 | ~10 miles (via Verrazzano) |
| Elizabeth, NJ | ~30 | ~5 miles (via Goethals) |
| Bayonne, NJ | ~15 | ~4 miles (via Bayonne Bridge) |
| Manhattan, NY | ~35 | ~15 miles (via Ferry/Tunnel) |
| St. George, Staten Island | ~5 | ~4 miles |
| New Dorp, Staten Island | ~5 | ~2 miles |
| Tottenville, Staten Island | ~3 | ~8 miles |
| Richmondtown, Staten Island | ~2 | ~1 mile |
| Linden, NJ | ~10 | ~7 miles (via Goethals) |
Useful Tips for Drivers in Staten Island
- Lowest Prices in NYC: Capitalize on the lower taxes. Staten Island almost always has the cheapest gas within the five boroughs. Costco is usually the absolute lowest.
- Bridge Access is Key: Many popular stations are located near the entrances/exits for the Verrazzano, Goethals, and Bayonne bridges, catering to drivers heading to/from Brooklyn and New Jersey.
- Richmond Ave & Hylan Blvd: These are the two main commercial arteries running north-south through the island, hosting a large concentration of gas stations.
- Diesel and Propane: Diesel fuel is relatively easy to find due to truck traffic using I-278 and the bridges. Propane (LP Gas) filling stations are less common but available at select larger service stations or specialized suppliers.
- Check NJ Prices: While Staten Island is cheap for NYC, prices in neighboring New Jersey (especially away from the bridges) can sometimes be even lower due to NJ’s different gas tax structure. It might be worth comparing if you’re crossing into NJ anyway.
Curiosity: The Verrazzano Toll Factor
For drivers coming from other boroughs, the significant toll on the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge ($20+ without discounts) must be factored into gas savings calculations. The savings on a single tank might not offset the toll unless you have an E-ZPass with a resident discount or are making the trip for other reasons.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
- Why is gas generally cheaper in Staten Island than the rest of NYC?
- Staten Island (Richmond County) has lower local taxes compared to the other four boroughs. Additionally, less dense development allows for larger gas station lots, potentially leading to higher volume sales and more competitive pricing, similar to suburban areas.
- Is it worth driving to Staten Island just for gas?
- It depends on where you’re coming from and how much gas you need. Factor in the cost of tolls (like the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge) and your time. For drivers already in nearby Brooklyn or New Jersey, or those with large tanks (like trucks or SUVs), the savings can be significant, especially when filling up at places like Costco.
- Are there many stations near the Staten Island Ferry Terminal?
- There are a few stations in the St. George area near the ferry terminal, but the selection increases as you move further south along Bay Street or Richmond Terrace. Prices might be slightly higher right near the terminal due to convenience.
s
- Where can I find stations that sell propane (LP Gas) in Staten Island?
- Propane filling stations are less common than gasoline stations. Look for larger service stations, home heating oil suppliers, or specific propane dealers. Some U-Haul locations also offer propane refills. It’s best to call ahead to confirm availability and hours for propane services.
Ranking: The 10 Best Gas Stations in Staten Island
This AZ New York list highlights the best gas stations in Staten Island, focusing on the absolute lowest prices (Costco), strategic locations near bridges and the expressway, availability of various fuel types (including diesel), and overall service quality.
1. Costco Gas Station (Richmond Ave)
Address: 2975 Richmond Ave, Staten Island, NY 10314
Telefone: (718) 982-9525
Site: costco.com
Services: Top Tier Regular (87), Top Tier Premium (93), Air Pump.
Justification: The undisputed champion for the cheapest gas prices not just in Staten Island, but likely all of NYC. Extremely popular (expect lines), members-only, but the savings on Top Tier fuel are significant. Centrally located on Richmond Ave.
2. Sunoco (Goethals Bridge / South Ave)
Address: 700 South Ave, Staten Island, NY 10303
Telefone: (718) 982-9203
Site: sunoco.com
Services: Top Tier Gasoline, Diesel, Convenience Store, Restrooms, 24/7.
Justification: Strategically vital location right before the Goethals Bridge entrance, making it the last chance to fuel up in NY before heading to NJ. Offers diesel and is open 24/7, catering to commercial traffic.
3. Mobil (Verrazzano Bridge Vicinity / Hylan Blvd)
Address: 1775 South Ave, Staten Island, NY 10314 (Near SI Expressway) – *Verifying best Verrazzano option – this one is near SIE* – Alternative: Shell at 1635 Hylan Blvd.
Telefone: (718) 494-0600 (for 1775 South Ave Mobil)
Site: exxon.com (for 1775 South Ave Mobil)
Services: Synergy™ Gasoline, Convenience Store, 24/7.
Justification: This Mobil (or the nearby Shell on Hylan) is well-positioned for drivers using the Staten Island Expressway (I-278) heading towards or coming from the Verrazzano Bridge. Reliable brands offering fuel before the bridge toll.
4. Shell (Bayonne Bridge Vicinity / Richmond Terrace)
Address: 35B Richmond Terrace, Staten Island, NY 10301
Telefone: (718) 273-0370
Site: shell.com
Services: Shell V-Power NiTRO+, Convenience Store, 24/7.
Justification: Key location near the Bayonne Bridge entrance/exit on the North Shore. A convenient 24/7 Shell gas station for drivers going to or coming from Bayonne, NJ.
5. BP (New Dorp / Hylan Blvd)
Address: 2450 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10306
Telefone: (718) 351-9311
Site: bp.com
Services: Gasoline with Amoco Invigorate, Convenience Store.
Justification: Serves the central Staten Island neighborhood of New Dorp along the busy Hylan Boulevard corridor. A reliable BP fuel station with competitive pricing for the area.
6. Delta (Great Kills / Amboy Rd)
Address: 3985 Amboy Rd, Staten Island, NY 10308
Telefone: (718) 948-4712
Site: (Delta stations are often independent – no central site link typical)
Services: Gasoline, Often lower prices (check Top Tier status).
Justification: Delta stations are known for often having very competitive, cheap gas prices. This location serves the Great Kills area on Amboy Road, offering potential savings over major brands.
7. Sunoco (Rossville / Arthur Kill Rd)
Address: 1781 Arthur Kill Rd, Staten Island, NY 10312
Telefone: (718) 948-1027
Site: sunoco.com
Services: Top Tier Gasoline, Diesel, Restrooms.
Justification: Located on the western side of the island in Rossville, serving traffic on Arthur Kill Road and near the Outerbridge Crossing approach. Offers diesel fuel.
8. Mobil (St. George / Bay St)
Address: 231 Bay St, Staten Island, NY 10301
Telefone: (718) 448-9366
Site: exxon.com
Services: Synergy™ Gasoline, Convenience Store.
Justification: One of the closest major brand stations to the Staten Island Ferry terminal in St. George. Convenient for ferry commuters and residents of the North Shore.
9. Shell (Tottenville / Amboy Rd)
Address: 6937 Amboy Rd, Staten Island, NY 10309
Telefone: (718) 967-0099
Site: shell.com
Services: Shell V-Power NiTRO+, Convenience Store.
Justification: Located in Tottenville, the southernmost neighborhood in NYC. Serves residents of the South Shore and is one of the last stops before the Outerbridge Crossing.
10. Gulf (Travis / Victory Blvd)
Address: 1956 Victory Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10314
Telefone: (718) 698-9635
Site: gulfoil.com
Services: Gulf Gasoline, Diesel, Convenience Store, Auto Repair.
Justification: Serves the western part of Staten Island near the Travis neighborhood. Offers diesel and auto repair, located on Victory Boulevard, a major crosstown route.
Found even cheaper gas in Staten Island? Let everyone know where in the comments!
Check out other gas station guides:
- 10 Best Gas Stations in New York City
- 10 Best Gas Stations in Queens, NY
- 10 Best Gas Stations in Brooklyn, NY
- 10 Best Gas Stations in Manhattan, NY
- 10 Best Gas Stations in The Bronx, NY
Keywords for your next internet search
best gas stations Staten Island NY, cheapest gas Staten Island, cheap gas NYC, gas prices Staten Island, Costco gas Staten Island, gas near Verrazzano Bridge, gas near Goethals Bridge, gas near Bayonne Bridge, Richmond Ave gas station, Hylan Blvd gas station, 24 hour gas station Staten Island, diesel fuel near me Staten Island, propane filling station near me Staten Island, Top Tier gas Staten Island, Shell Staten Island, Mobil Staten Island, Sunoco Staten Island, find cheap gas near me, cheapest gas prices near me, lowest gas prices near me Staten Island, petrol station near me.
