Complete Guide: The 10 Best Gas Stations in Nassau County, NY | Long Island Guide
Complete Guide: The 10 Best Gas Stations in Nassau County, NY | Long Island Guide
By: AZ New York Staff
Nassau County: Fueling Long Island’s Western Hub
As the gateway between New York City and the rest of Long Island, Nassau County is a heavily trafficked suburban area with a high density of vehicles. Major commuter routes like the Long Island Expressway (LIE/I-495), Northern State Parkway, Southern State Parkway, Hempstead Turnpike, and Sunrise Highway crisscross the county. With approximately 535 gas stations, Nassau offers more competitive pricing than NYC’s boroughs (except Staten Island) and a wide variety of brands and services for residents and commuters heading east to Suffolk County or west into Queens.
| County / Borough / City | Approx. Nº of Stations | Approx. Distance (from Central Nassau) |
|---|---|---|
| Nassau County, NY | ~535 | 0 miles |
| Queens, NY | ~370 | ~7 miles |
| Suffolk County, NY | ~760 | ~10 miles (from border) |
| Brooklyn, NY | ~280 | ~15 miles |
| Hempstead, NY | ~20 | ~3 miles |
| Levittown, NY | ~15 | ~4 miles |
| Hicksville, NY | ~15 | ~6 miles |
| Valley Stream, NY | ~10 | ~8 miles |
| Mineola, NY | ~10 | ~3 miles |
| Massapequa, NY | ~15 | ~10 miles |
Useful Tips for Drivers in Nassau County
- Major Routes = More Options: Stick to the main Turnpikes (Hempstead, Jericho) and Boulevards (Northern, Sunrise Highway) for the widest selection of stations and potentially better prices due to competition.
- Parkway Pitfalls: Gas stations directly *on* the Northern and Southern State Parkways are very limited and always significantly more expensive. Exit the parkway onto major local roads to refuel.
- Costco & BJ’s Value: Like in NYC, membership clubs Costco (Westbury, Oceanside) and BJ’s Wholesale Club (multiple locations) offer Top Tier gasoline at considerably lower prices than standard stations. Lines can be long.
- Check Suffolk Prices: If traveling further east, prices in Suffolk County might be slightly lower than in Nassau, though the difference is usually less pronounced than the Nassau/NYC difference.
- Diesel Availability: Diesel fuel is widely available at many branded stations (Shell, BP, Sunoco, Mobil/Exxon) along major routes catering to commercial traffic and trucks using the LIE.
Curiosity: The “Gasoline Alley” Phenomenon
Certain stretches of major roads in Nassau, like parts of Hempstead Turnpike or Sunrise Highway, become veritable “Gasoline Alleys” with multiple stations clustered together, sometimes even across the street from each other. This high concentration often leads to intense price competition, making these areas good spots to find cheaper gas if you shop around.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
- Is gas typically cheaper in Nassau County compared to NYC?
- Generally, yes. Nassau County usually has lower gas prices than Queens, Brooklyn, The Bronx, and especially Manhattan, due to lower taxes and operating costs. However, prices can still be higher than in neighboring Suffolk County or New Jersey.
- Are gas stations in Nassau County mostly self-serve or full-serve?
- New York State allows both. While many stations are self-serve or offer both options, you will find some full-service-only stations, particularly older, smaller ones. Note that New Jersey, just across the bridges from NYC, mandates full service statewide.
- Where are gas stations most concentrated in Nassau County?
- Stations are heavily concentrated along major east-west arteries like Hempstead Turnpike (Route 24), Sunrise Highway (Route 27), Jericho Turnpike (Route 25), and Northern Boulevard (Route 25A), as well as near exits of the Long Island Expressway (I-495) and the parkways (Northern State, Southern State).
s
- Do Nassau County stations offer cash discounts like in NYC?
- Yes, the practice of offering a discount (typically 5-10 cents per gallon) for cash payment is also common in Nassau County, particularly at independent stations but sometimes at branded ones too. Always check the price signs carefully.
Ranking: The 10 Best Gas Stations in Nassau County
This AZ New York list identifies top gas stations across Nassau County, emphasizing value (Costco/BJ’s), strategic locations near major highways and parkways, brand reliability, 24-hour access, and availability of diesel fuel.
1. Costco Gas Station (Westbury)
Address: 1250 Old Country Rd, Westbury, NY 11590
Telefone: (516) 357-2003
Site: costco.com (Closest warehouse link, verify gas location)
Services: Top Tier Regular (87), Top Tier Premium (93).
Justification: A major destination for cheap gas in central Nassau. Located conveniently off the Northern State Parkway and near Roosevelt Field mall. Expect lines, especially on weekends (members only).
2. BJ’s Gas Station (Levittown)
Address: 3635 Hempstead Turnpike, Levittown, NY 11756
Telefone: (516) 579-2220
Site: bjs.com
Services: Top Tier Regular (87), Premium (93), Diesel.
Justification: Another excellent membership club option for low-priced Top Tier fuel, including diesel. Located directly on Hempstead Turnpike in Levittown, a major thoroughfare.
3. Shell (Hicksville / LIE Exit 41)
Address: 235 N Broadway, Hicksville, NY 11801
Telefone: (516) 931-1510
Site: shell.com
Services: Shell V-Power NiTRO+, Diesel, Convenience Store, 24/7.
Justification: Strategically located just off LIE Exit 41S in Hicksville. A reliable 24/7 Shell offering premium fuel and diesel, convenient for highway travelers.
4. Mobil (Garden City / Stewart Ave)
Address: 800 Stewart Ave, Garden City, NY 11530
Telefone: (516) 222-7770
Site: exxon.com
Services: Synergy™ Gasoline, Convenience Store, Car Wash.
Justification: Serves the busy commercial area of Garden City near Roosevelt Field and Hofstra University. Offers a car wash and reliable Mobil fuel.
5. BP (Valley Stream / Sunrise Hwy)
Address: 720 W Sunrise Hwy, Valley Stream, NY 11581
Telefone: (516) 825-7800
Site: bp.com
Services: Gasoline with Amoco Invigorate, Diesel, Convenience Store, 24/7.
Justification: Located on Sunrise Highway in Valley Stream, close to the Queens border and JFK Airport approaches. A 24/7 option with diesel fuel.
6. Sunoco (Massapequa / Sunrise Hwy)
Address: 5440 Sunrise Hwy, Massapequa, NY 11758
Telefone: (516) 799-9742
Site: sunoco.com
Services: Top Tier Gasoline, Diesel, Convenience Store, 24/7.
Justification: Serves the South Shore community of Massapequa along Sunrise Highway. Reliable 24/7 Sunoco with diesel, useful for travelers heading towards Suffolk County beaches.
7. Shell (Great Neck / Northern Blvd)
Address: 595 Northern Blvd, Great Neck, NY 11021
Telefone: (516) 487-0744
Site: shell.com
Services: Shell V-Power NiTRO+, Convenience Store, 24/7.
Justification: Located on the North Shore’s busy Northern Boulevard (25A) in Great Neck, near the Queens border. Convenient 24/7 stop for North Shore residents and commuters.
8. Exxon (Mineola / Jericho Tpke)
Address: 400 Jericho Turnpike, Mineola, NY 11501
Telefone: (516) 746-9860
Site: exxon.com
Services: Synergy™ Gasoline, Diesel, Convenience Store, Auto Repair.
Justification: Positioned on Jericho Turnpike in Mineola, the county seat. Offers diesel fuel and auto repair services, serving central Nassau traffic.
9. Speedway (Hempstead / Hempstead Tpke)
Address: 138 Peninsula Blvd, Hempstead, NY 11550
Telefone: (516) 481-9721
Site: speedway.com
Services: Speedway Gasoline (often Top Tier), Convenience Store (often extensive), Speedy Rewards.
Justification: Speedway stations (part of 7-Eleven) are known for competitive pricing and well-stocked convenience stores. This location serves the busy Hempstead area.
10. Gulf (Roslyn Heights / LIE Service Rd)
Address: 25 Northern Blvd (LIE North Service Rd), Roslyn Heights, NY 11577
Telefone: (516) 621-9751
Site: gulfoil.com
Services: Gulf Gasoline (Top Tier), Convenience Store, 24/7.
Justification: Conveniently located directly on the North Service Road of the LIE near Exit 37 in Roslyn Heights. An easy on/off stop for highway travelers needing 24/7 fuel.
Have a favorite gas station in Nassau County? Share your tips and finds in the comments below!
Check out other gas station guides:
- 10 Best Gas Stations in New York City
- 10 Best Gas Stations in Queens, NY
- 10 Best Gas Stations in Brooklyn, NY
- 10 Best Gas Stations in Manhattan, NY
- 10 Best Gas Stations in The Bronx, NY
- 10 Best Gas Stations in Staten Island, NY
- 10 Best Gas Stations in Suffolk County, NY (Coming Soon)
Keywords for your next internet search
best gas stations Nassau County NY, gas prices Long Island, cheap gas Nassau County, Top Tier gas Long Island, Costco gas Westbury, BJ’s gas Levittown, gas near LIE Long Island, gas near Northern State Parkway, gas near Southern State Parkway, Hempstead Turnpike gas stations, Sunrise Highway gas stations, 24 hour gas station Nassau County, cash vs credit gas price Long Island, cheapest premium gas near me Nassau County, diesel fuel near me Nassau County, gas station near me now Long Island, closest gas station to my location Nassau, Shell near me LI, Mobil Garden City, find nearest gas station Long Island, cheapest gas prices near me LI.
