10 Best Hardware & Building Supply Stores in NYC
By: AZ New York Editorial Team
For professional contractors, serious DIY renovators, and historic homeowners, NYC’s corner bodega just won’t do. You need pro-grade materials, expert knowledge, and stores that can handle bulk orders of lumber and drywall. Start with our definitive guide:
10 Best Hardware & Building Supply Stores in NYC — featuring independent yards, pro-level suppliers, and historic shops with deep expertise in the city’s unique building stock.
Bushwick, Brooklyn: NYC’s Epicenter for Industrial-to-Residential Conversion
Bushwick is a prime example of New York City’s constant reinvention, located in northern Brooklyn. This neighborhood is a global hub for adaptive reuse projects, operating under the jurisdiction of the City of New York—an official .gov entity.
With a population of approximately 130,000 residents (NYC Planning, 2025) and a median sale price soaring to $1.16M, Bushwick is a high-stakes market. The neighborhood is defined by its transition from industrial warehouses to artist lofts, residential condos, and renovated pre-war brownstones.
The real estate market is dominated by industrial-to-residential conversions and new construction, with 8- and 14-story residential towers rising alongside historic brick factories. This creates a massive, specialized demand for building materials far beyond typical home improvement.
Transit is robust: the L and M subway lines provide direct access to Manhattan and Queens. The B57 and B60 buses connect the neighborhood’s commercial and industrial corridors.
The local economy is built for renovation: 8+ lumber yards, 12+ specialty paint suppliers (including extensive Low-VOC options), 5 tool rental depots, and numerous commercial supply houses specializing in drywall, metal studs, and masonry.
| Area / Neighborhood | Est. Pro Suppliers | Market Profile |
|---|---|---|
| Bushwick, Brooklyn | ~ 25+ | Industrial Conversions / Pro Supply |
| Williamsburg, Brooklyn | ~ 15 | Boutique Finishes / High-End |
| Long Island City, Queens | ~ 20 | New Construction / Bulk Drywall |
| Harlem, Manhattan | ~ 18 | Brownstone Restoration / Paint |
| Mott Haven, Bronx | ~ 22 | Commercial Yards / Lumber |
| Gowanus, Brooklyn | ~ 12 | Tile & Stone / Rezoning |
| Hell’s Kitchen, Manhattan | ~ 10 | Contractor Services / High-Density |
| Sunset Park, Brooklyn | ~ 15 | Lumber Imports / Cabinetry |
| Flushing, Queens | ~ 20 | Plumbing & Electrical / New Dev |
| East Village, Manhattan | ~ 8 | DIY / Paint / Superintendents |
3 Common Scenarios in NYC’s Renovation Market
- The Brownstone Restoration
The Situation: A homeowner in Harlem needs to replace 80 feet of damaged 1910-era crown molding and match the original stain.
The Solution: A pro lumber yard with millwork services (like Dykes or Lumber Boys) sources the correct wood species and uses a custom knife to replicate the molding profile exactly. - The Loft Conversion
The Situation: A contractor is framing 12 new apartments inside a former Bushwick warehouse and needs materials delivered *now*.
The Solution: A commercial building supplier (like Feldman or Metropolitan) arranges a boom truck delivery for 150 sheets of 5/8″ Type X drywall, 200 steel studs, and 100 bags of joint compound. - The Co-op Paint Job
The Situation: An Upper West Side co-op board requires a painter to use a specific, high-end, low-VOC paint (Benjamin Moore Aura) in all common areas.
The Solution: A specialty paint store (like Beacon) has the entire line in stock, provides an expert color match, and sets up a pro account for the painter.
Curiosity: What’s the Difference Between a Hardware Store and a Lumber Yard?
A hardware store (like Garber or Basics Plus) is for “the bolts”: tools, paint, keys, plumbing fixtures, and electrical parts. A lumber yard or building supplier (like Feldman or Elmax) is for “the bones”: lumber, drywall, steel studs, masonry, and insulation, often sold in bulk to contractors.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
- What is “Custom Millwork”?
- This is the service of custom-milling wood. It’s essential in NYC for replicating historic baseboards, crown molding, or window casings found in pre-war brownstones and apartments.
- Do these stores deliver to 5th-floor walk-ups?
- Yes, but always confirm. Pro suppliers (like Metropolitan) have fleets of trucks, including boom trucks, for heavy materials. Local hardware stores often offer same-day delivery for smaller items.
- What is a “Pro Account”?
- An account for licensed contractors and builders. It typically offers bulk pricing, lines of credit, and dedicated sales representatives for managing large orders.
- What are Low-VOC paints?
- “Volatile Organic Compounds” are chemicals that off-gas into the air. Many NYC co-op boards and new developments mandate the use of Low-VOC or Zero-VOC paints for better indoor air quality.
Ranking: The 10 Best Hardware & Building Supply Stores in NYC
The AZ New York selection includes only pro-level suppliers and independent stores with deep expertise, bulk material access, and specialized services for the NYC renovation market.
1. H. Brickman & Sons
Address: 55 1st Ave, New York, NY 10003 (Multiple Locations)
Phone: (212) 674-3213
WhatsApp: +1 (212) 674-3213
Hours: Mon–Fri 7:30AM–6PM, Sat 9AM–5PM, Sun 10AM–5PM
Website: hbrickman.com
Services: Paint, Hardware, Building Material, Tools, Superintendent Supplies
Justification: A family-owned NYC institution with over 80 years of experience. They are the ultimate resource for contractors, DIYers, and building superintendents in Manhattan.
2. Metropolitan Lumber & Hardware
Address: 617 11th Ave, New York, NY 10036 (Multiple Locations)
Phone: (212) 246-9090
WhatsApp: +1 (212) 246-9090
Hours: Mon–Fri 6AM–4PM
Website: metlumber.com
Services: Lumber, Drywall, Steel Studs, Masonry, Boom Truck Delivery
Justification: A massive, pro-level supplier with a 5-acre flagship lumberyard. This is where contractors go for bulk orders and heavy materials, with a fleet of trucks for city-wide delivery.
3. Dykes Lumber Company
Address: 137 W 24th St, New York, NY 10011 (Multiple Locations)
Phone: (212) 675-1111
WhatsApp: +1 (212) 675-1111
Hours: Mon–Fri 7AM–4:30PM
Website: dykeslumber.com
Services: Custom Millwork, Lumber, Moulding, Doors, Wallboards, Decking
Justification: Founded in 1909, Dykes is the unparalleled expert in high-grade lumber and custom millwork, essential for restoring historic NYC brownstones and pre-war co-ops.
4. Beacon Paint & Hardware
Address: 371 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024
Phone: (212) 408-1681
WhatsApp: +1 (212) 408-1681
Hours: Mon–Fri 8AM–7PM, Sat 9AM–7PM, Sun 10AM–6PM
Website: beaconpaint.com
Services: Benjamin Moore Paint, Expert Color Matching, Hardware, Supplies
Justification: An Upper West Side landmark. This is not just a paint store; it’s a consultation service. Renowned for its incredibly knowledgeable staff and deep stock of high-end paints.
5. Feldman Lumber
Address: 1139 Flushing Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11237 (Multiple Locations)
Phone: (718) 746-7500
WhatsApp: +1 (718) 746-7500
Hours: Mon–Fri 6AM–4:30PM, Sat 7AM–12PM
Website: feldmanlumber.com
Services: Lumber, Plywood, Drywall, Insulation, Commercial Doors, Pro Accounts
Justification: A leading pro-supplier serving the entire metro area. Their Brooklyn location is a key hub for the Bushwick and Williamsburg renovation boom, stocking heavy-duty building materials.
6. Garber Hardware
Address: 710 Greenwich St, New York, NY 10014
Phone: (212) 929-3030
WhatsApp: +1 (212) 929-3030
Hours: Mon–Fri 8AM–7PM, Sat 9AM–5PM, Sun 10AM–4PM
Website: garberhardware.com
Services: General Hardware, Tools, Plumbing, Electrical, Paint, Key Cutting
Justification: The quintessential West Village hardware store. Incredibly well-stocked for its size, with a famously knowledgeable staff that can find any obscure part you need for a pre-war apartment.
7. Elmax Builders Supply Co.
Address: 430 E 138th St, Bronx, NY 10454
Phone: (718) 588-0220
WhatsApp: +1 (718) 588-0220
Hours: Mon–Fri 6:30AM–4:30PM, Sat 7AM–12PM
Website: elmaxlumber.net
Services: Building Materials, Lumber, Drywall, Tile, Steel, Masonry
Justification: A Bronx-based, full-service building supply company for over 60 years. It’s a one-stop-shop for contractors in the Bronx and Upper Manhattan needing heavy materials.
8. Lumber Boys
Address: 699 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10016
Phone: (212) 683-0410
WhatsApp: +1 (212) 683-0410
Hours: Mon–Fri 7:30AM–5PM, Sat 9AM–1PM
Website: lumberboys.com
Services: Lumber, Hardware, Plywood, Moulding, Contractor & Architect Resource
Justification: The go-to lumber yard for contractors and architects in Murray Hill. They specialize in sourcing specific wood types and cuts for custom jobs in Manhattan’s high-rises.
9. Corner Hardware (Ace)
Address: 2266 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11210
Phone: (718) 927-4300
WhatsApp: +1 (718) 927-4300
Hours: Mon–Thurs 7AM–7PM, Fri 7AM–3PM, Sun 8AM–4PM
Website: acehardware.com/store-details/10236
Services: Paint, Hardware, Kitchen & Bath Showroom, Tiles, Cabinets
Justification: This is a locally-owned Ace franchise that acts like a pro-supplier. It features a showroom for tiles, cabinets, and marble, making it a key resource for Brooklyn renovators.
10. Basics Plus
Address: 91 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10003 (Multiple Locations)
Phone: (917) 893-3560
WhatsApp: +1 (917) 893-3560
Hours: Mon–Sun 9AM–8PM
Website: basicsplus.com
Services: Hardware, Housewares, Key Cutting, AC Installation, Knife Sharpening
Justification: A reliable local chain that bridges the gap between housewares and hardware. Perfect for DIYers and renters who need tools, AC installation, and other home services.
And you—what’s your top hardware store or lumber yard in NYC? Share your recommendation in the comments and help other contractors and renovators build smarter!
Explore More “Best of NYC” Guides:
Keywords for Your Next Search:
best hardware stores NYC, NYC building supplies, lumber yards Brooklyn, contractor supply Manhattan, historic renovation supplies NYC, pro hardware stores NYC, Benjamin Moore dealer NYC, custom millwork NYC, drywall delivery NYC, local hardware store, Elmax Bronx, Dykes Lumber, Metropolitan Lumber, Beacon Paint, Garber Hardware
